So I have two dermatologists (at two different clinics in two different cities), a man and a woman. I recently saw the man and asked about taking off eye makeup. He recommended to me: Hydrating Cream-to-Foam Cleanser | Facial Cleanser | CeraVe

It does not fully remove my eye makeup. I have traces of it next morning.

The thing is, even with double cleanse, first body oil and then this thing or the Vanicream cleanser, even if I do not see eye makeup when I cleanse, I sometimes have black stuff next morning. I am not doing things right, clearly.

On Monday I will see my female dermatologist and will bring these cleansers to her office and ask her what I am doing wrong or whether she recommends other products. Hopefully she will be more helpful than the guy (who is a doll, but he just has never removed makeup himself, quite clearly).