I like the Depp version better than the Wilder version. I found Dahl so funny as a child that the creepiness was not the same to me. I laugh out loud at Dahl. I didn't really find Mary Poppins funny at all. I liked the disney version because I have always had a crush on Julie Andrews - even in 10 I was for her and not Bo Derek (and why anyone wants Dudley Moore is beyond me -but he is also funny).