View Single Post
 
Old Feb 04, 2009, 02:45 PM
the final coda the final coda is offline
Junior Member
 
Member Since: Feb 2009
Posts: 6
Quote:
Originally Posted by chaotic13 View Post
My only comment here is..you have clearly investigated the information available on this topic and have reached this conclusion. It works for you. However as a educated health care professional you should realize that calling a practioner, that offers a treatment that you yourself acknowledge COULD be benefifical, guilty of fraud is not appropriate. I think you need to have a discussion with your EBM professor. In the practice model there are two other equally important components of EBM (the clinican's skills and the PATIENT). It is not just about the research.
You're right. I should qualify the statement as personal opinion, because it is. I stand by it though. When I say that Reiki could be beneficial, it's because I'm thinking in terms of probability, and I acknowledge that there is always some error enherent in our evaluations and conclusions (science is theoretically humble, so physics, despite its fields internal and external consistency, could theoretically be totally wrong). That said, I would equate Reiki's potential for benefiting it's clients in the way that it claims to (manipulating energy fields), as roughly equivalent to the likelihood that thinking about bending the spoon will actually make it bend. It's possible, but since it contradicts the laws of physics and pretty much everything else we observe in the natural world and our daily lives, we have to assume it implausable until some form of quality evidence forces us to reevaluate that position.

At what point do things become fraudulent? If someone claims something, sells things based upon that claim, and their claim is false beyond any sort of reasonble doubt, then its fraudulent. Am I wrong?

I'm also not sure I follow as to why you then point out clinician skills and the patient are also important components of EBM. I don't disagree, but I'm not sure how its relevant here. Reiki either manipulates energy fields to boost "general health and well being" or it doesn't. Could you flesh that out?

Thanks