FAQ/Help |
Calendar |
Search |
Member
Member Since Aug 2019
Location: The World
Posts: 278
4 16 hugs
given |
#1
In my last session before the break we are currently on, my very angry little child came hurtling out at full force for the very first time in front of my T. I believe there was some dissociation going on as I don’t fully recall exactly what was said, but the one thing I do remember was my response to his response. After the angry outburst he sat in his chair all calm, half smiling and told me he was ok with me being angry and he could take it and it wasn’t a problem. My reaction to this was that is made me even more angry. I didn’t want him to be fine with it, I didn’t want it to have no effect on him, I wanted him to feel something. Because if he was angry at me for being angry, or was annoyed or hurt, then at least that reaction would show that he cared. Sitting there, seemingly unfazed and relaxed felt like he doesn’t consider me important enough or care enough about me to react to me being angry at him. I didn’t tell him any of this as it felt extremely shameful that I clearly wanted to provoke a reaction out of him.
I’ve never really heard anyone say they have experienced this kind of thing so just wondering if anyone else felt anything similar or am I just weird?! |
Reply With Quote |
Favorite Jeans, Jellybean8, RoxanneToto, SalingerEsme, SlumberKitty, Taylor27
|
Member
Member Since Sep 2020
Location: Scotland
Posts: 148
3 9 hugs
given |
#2
I spoke angrily to my first T on just one occasion, and she replied to me in a slightly emotionally charged way, with some words that were a little bit holding. Sometime later one of my teenage children was speaking angrily to me, which was usual for her, and I stayed with her, in a different way than I ever had before, and replied to her, maybe in a similar way to my T, and I believe that moment changed my daughter. I think that maybe your instinct that his reaction wasn’t entirely helpful is true, we need our T’s to be in some way emotionally involved with us, to be moved by our sorrow, and our anger, and to be genuinely present with us.
|
Reply With Quote |
Favorite Jeans, Jellybean8, RoxanneToto
|
*Beth*, comrademoomoo, Jellybean8, KLL85, RoxanneToto
|
Magnate
Member Since Oct 2018
Location: USA
Posts: 2,788
5 7 hugs
given |
#3
Accepting your anger without getting angry back, without "punishment," IS caring. That's what good parents do (or therapists in this case). Is it possible you expected what you "know" from childhood and this caring acceptance is foreign to you?
Kids act out to be heard when they are used to not being heard, and they don't always particularly care what the reaction is so long as they don't feel invisible. I see it in students on occasion who will get attention any way they can get it, even if it means negative attention. It's a learned behavior. Kids who are used to being heard by attentive adults tend to act out less often and with less vigor. They'll still do it, but when met with the same consistent acceptance and caring, with redirection rather than punishment, they will generally calm fairly quickly and be okay. What your therapist is doing is modeling acceptance and caring of you, even at your "worst." But you may not recognize that's is what is going on. |
Reply With Quote |
*Beth*, just2b, KLL85, RoxanneToto
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Feb 2019
Location: Toodlepip
Posts: 1,720
5 |
#4
I find it infuriating when my therapist says that she welcomes my anger. It is as if I am rendered impotent. Don't welcome it, react to it! Fall into my old patterns and let us play out roles where we shout and hurt each other.
Engaging in conflict is a type of connection. It's hurtful and difficult and draining, but it is a kind of contact. Sometimes I like teasing my cat to make him angry so I can see him interact with me. Is anger a familiar emotion for you? What were the dominant feelings in your childhood home and were you allowed to express them? |
Reply With Quote |
KLL85
|
Member
Member Since Aug 2019
Location: The World
Posts: 278
4 16 hugs
given |
#5
Quote:
|
|
Reply With Quote |
Member
Member Since Aug 2019
Location: The World
Posts: 278
4 16 hugs
given |
#6
Quote:
|
|
Reply With Quote |
RoxanneToto
|
catches the flowers
Member Since Jul 2019
Location: Downtown Vibes, California
Posts: 15,701
(SuperPoster!)
4 23.7k hugs
given |
#7
__________________ |
Reply With Quote |
comrademoomoo
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Feb 2019
Location: Toodlepip
Posts: 1,720
5 |
#8
|
Reply With Quote |
*Beth*, RoxanneToto
|
*Beth*, RoxanneToto
|
Member
Member Since Aug 2019
Location: Hungary
Posts: 142
4 65 hugs
given |
#9
Quote:
I think there's a difference between feeling the weight of our anger and being able to take it on and pretending it has no weight ... or, worse, it really being nothing to them. Might be a good idea to discuss this further with your T. Quote:
Whenever ex-T did that, it always just made me wipe the smile off her face. **** you, I'm angry because I'm hurt and/or scared, and that's because of what you did/said (or didn't), don't you dare smile! (and yes, transference and past traumas and blah-blah, but she was still the one triggering it in that moment) The part of me that kind of wants to express itself but kind of doesn't and so it all comes out as anger, wanted to hear that it's existence and intent to communicte is dscovered and acknwedged. The part of me that knows it's not OK to express anger that way (or express anger at all when I really need to express something ele) wanted to hear that it's not OK, because anything else is lie, but also that it's acceptable in that context until I learn to express myself better, and this ties back to the previous point - understanding that something needs to b expressed but I need help to get to a point where I can. The calm-welcoming supposedly oh-so-professional reaction I from exT, gave me none of this, I only felt (even more) invisible and impotent and even angrier. Of course, her apparent calm and welcoming attitude wasn't entirely honest in the first place, as I suspected and she later confirmed ("btw it's kind of scary when you get angry") |
||
Reply With Quote |
SlumberKitty
|
Quietmind 2, RoxanneToto
|
Grand Magnate
Member Since Jun 2018
Location: Somewhere
Posts: 3,355
5 1 hugs
given |
#10
I would have felt the same way. I don't pay the therapist to not respond to what I bring to therapy. While I don't expect her to care deeply on a personal level that I am angry, she is providing a service and, unless she is ambivalent about retaining clients, should care about the discord on a professional level. My head would probably explode if I expressed anger at her and she just sat there smiling like an idiot. Sometimes she has said she doesn't know how to respond to something I am angry about, and I can work with that, but just saying it's ok wouldn't cut it. At all. And I would probably feel patronized that she felt she needed to tell me it was ok (although I know this could be helpful to people who have problems expressing anger).
Maybe the smiling and dismissing of your anger was a defense mechanism on the part of your therapist? __________________ Life is hard. Then you die. Then they throw dirt in your face. -David Gerrold |
Reply With Quote |
Quietmind 2
|
Grand Magnate
Member Since Jun 2018
Location: Somewhere
Posts: 3,355
5 1 hugs
given |
#11
I don't disagree that might be their intention, but how very unnatural! People in real life do not respond this way unless they just don't care. Or, I suppose, if a parent is too tired to engage with a tantruming child. I'm left wondering what the point is of modeling such a bizarre response that will never be replicated in life. Maybe it's me... I've been equally baffled by other things therapists are said to model.
__________________ Life is hard. Then you die. Then they throw dirt in your face. -David Gerrold |
Reply With Quote |
Magnate
Member Since May 2017
Location: Earth
Posts: 2,515
6 4,704 hugs
given |
#12
Quote:
|
|
Reply With Quote |
corbie, SlumberKitty
|
*Beth*, Amyjay, ArtleyWilkins, corbie, RoxanneToto, Waterbear
|
Magnate
Member Since Mar 2017
Location: Underground
Posts: 2,439
7 692 hugs
given |
#13
Quote:
Who knew. But i agree with the poster above.. .teaching toddlers to regulate their emotions is where it all begins. If adults were able to teach toddlers how to feel, deal and express emotions in healthy ways most people wouldn't be in such a mess. But... we are in such a mess because the cycle just continues and people who can't express emotions and maintain healthy relationships (because they weren't taught how to do that by their own parents ) go on to emotionally harm their own children and pass own their own unhealthy relationship patterns. So kudos to the above poster who is teaching her toddler to regulate their emotions. Your toddler is one of the lucky ones. |
|
Reply With Quote |
ElectricManatee, SlumberKitty
|
ArtleyWilkins, ElectricManatee, Mystical_Being, Quietmind 2, RoxanneToto
|
Magnate
Member Since Oct 2018
Location: USA
Posts: 2,788
5 7 hugs
given |
#14
Quote:
|
|
Reply With Quote |
SlumberKitty
|
Quietmind 2, RoxanneToto
|
Member
Member Since Jan 2020
Location: In The Dojo
Posts: 196
4 1 hugs
given |
#15
Quote:
So, in your situation, I believe he cares for you. And he is showing that by letting you express what you need to express without him reacting. He is creating a very safe place for you. |
|
Reply With Quote |
Member
Member Since Aug 2019
Location: Hungary
Posts: 142
4 65 hugs
given |
#16
I think it's important to differentiate between a lack of angry response and acceptence. They are very far from being the same. Passive aggression is a thing. Masking fear (or displeasure) with apparent calm and a forced smile is a thing. I'm sure there are a lot of other possibilities where calm and controlled behaviour comes with a lack of acceptance. Conversely, someone's whose first reaction is to get angry back might actually be genuinely accepting after calming down (although that doesn't necessarily heal the damage done in anger).
I'm not saying the therapist in question is doing any of these. I suspect it was primarily a genuine attempt at reassurance, if not very attuned to th OP's need, but 1. the smiling and 2. the sole focus being on how it's ok and he can take it are red flags. Both can have perfectly sensible and harmless explanations, but still red flags. I might just be extra sensitive about this because of xT stuff, and other instances of getting into trouble because I explained away red flags like this (because, "maybe it's perfectly normal for normal people to behave this way or that, surely I'm just being paranoid" ... well no, many times I wasn't.) So please KLL85 don't be like me and convince yourself that you're just being stupid and decide it's not even worth talking about ... if his reaction rubs you the wrong way for whatever reason, that certainly is worth talking about. Quote:
Of course, the therapist in question is not interacting with an actual toddler, so it kind of makes sense that he'd try to verbally reassure the adult that it's ok, but I think the validation part would be necessary for me to parse it as acceptance, and, if being on the receiving end of a similar reaction, to actually help me regulate calm down and start trusting the person. |
|
Reply With Quote |
Wise Elder
Member Since Mar 2009
Location: 8CS / NYS / USA
Posts: 9,146
15 885 hugs
given |
#17
something my own therapists taught me... sometimes the best reaction is no reaction. I have a special needs child who sometimes cant regulate their own emotions and does have explosive anger. in therapy we were talking about my child and my own childhood. she noticed that when I talked about times I have gotten angry as an adult and child it wasnt the in kind reactions of others that made an impression on me. it was those few who did not react with anger that made the impressions on me that made me rethink how I was reacting and behaving and its what my child is doing. when you react to an angry situation you arte giving the child what they expect and want. you to be so angry at their explosion that you give in to what they want.
works the same way in therapy. if a therapist reacts to a clients anger with anger the thought is aha got her made her angry shes going to pay for what she said to me. but when the therapist sits calmly, rationally, logically 1 the situation cant continue spiralling out of control and 2 this unexpected reaction to a clients anger makes a huge inpression on the client. (point that shows this for example is the original poster would not have posted about this if it hadnt made some sort of impression on them where they felt they needed to post about it.) after they explained that to me I could count many times in my therapy where it was the calm and quiet reaction of my therapists that made an impression of some sort on me. and because I was no longer getting the expected response from them I stopped exploding anger over certain situations. my suggestion is look at the fact that for some reason this therapists reaction has made you think , made an impression on you of some kind and how their doing that is going to change your exploding in therapy. now because its made such a big inpressioon on you , maybe next time your anger wont be so explosive. maybe you will be able to like I did sit calmly and talk the problems out instead of exploding. |
Reply With Quote |
Magnate
Member Since Feb 2016
Location: England
Posts: 2,408
8 1,316 hugs
given |
#18
As soon as I read your post I thought of the parent child relationship. You see parents in the shops yelling at their children sometimes when the child acts out. You see them getting angry back at them. Sometimes you see parents in despair. Does that indicate that they care about the child? I'm not saying they don't care about the child but why is having a big response to a child acting out the only way to show caring. I think your therapist was holding your anger. Allowing it to be. Allowing you to express what is (apparently) a normal emotion. (I have serious issues with feeling and expressing anger) . I think him not being hurt by it shows more caring than blaming you. I think him not letting his feelings into the space is more caring than making it all about him. Just a thought.
|
Reply With Quote |
SlumberKitty
|
Reply |
|