View Single Post
 
Old Apr 15, 2018, 11:21 AM
OctobersBlackRose's Avatar
OctobersBlackRose OctobersBlackRose is offline
Magnate
 
Member Since: Jun 2012
Location: Michigan
Posts: 2,484
Quote:
Originally Posted by ArcheM View Post
Oof, yeah, that's a pickle. I mean, if I try to explain that without much thought, I fall back immediately on Russian, where those categories are... well, even more complex.

Although you do have an error in the second sentence. It's "Einen Hund hat meine Freundin."

Quite frankly, I can't come up with a context in which it would make sense. But, I think it would go better with the definite article. "Den Hund hat meine Freundin." So, "der Hund" has already been established. In this sentence you're conveying who exactly has the dog - "meine Freundin". Which is in the nominative case, whereas the dog is in the accusative (a direct object), although I imagine that doesn't help a lot. Or, following on from our earlier discussion about the multipurpose nature of the definite article, you could kind of reverse the sentence in the translation - "That (particular) dog belongs to my girlfriend." ...Let me now if that's even more confusing.
Again the error was due to autocorrect, I knew I wrote "meine", like I said in my other post it sometimes likes German while other times it doesn't.

And yeah I'm a little more confused now on word order.
__________________
Wir sind was wir sind

English

We are what we are

MDD w/psychotic features, BPD