Do you think emotional problems change with an evolving culture?

In trying to better handle my emotional life, I am beginning to see the following in the kinds of highly rated self-help books out there. They fall into two camps, it seems:

Increasingly popular:
* Emotions are overrated and tend to cause emotional reasoning, which is bad.
* Logic is so awesome it should be given a medal.
* Don't set your sights too high, you'll be disappointed and get learned helplessness.
* People tend to be too full of themselves and unreasonable because of it.
* "Ego" is bad.
* If you don't like your circumstances, its time to better adapt to them.
* When feeling depressed, take baby steps and don't trust your judgement, don't try to make any major changes.

Decreasingly popular:
* Validate your emotions, they have a message to convey, but be careful with Fear, it's the one that lies a lot.
* Thinking is often more of a problem then emotion because that is where cognitive distortions lie - emotions just follow them. The problem is negative expectations that seem logical.
* People get depressed because their expectations are too low and they need to be more assertive.
* Work on your self-esteem, and build your ego strength ... too many issues are caused by absorbed emotional invalidation.
* If you don't like your circumstances, you're playing in the wrong ballpark - find your niche.
* To fight depression, you might just need a lifestyle overhaul - DO make major changes.
* "Reasonable" means "think small and pessimistically" for too many people, so it's time to be UNreasonable!

So why oh why is it ... that for me the second set of assertions, and books and authors which say those things, seem to do me far more real good than the first, apparently increasingly popular type (still useful, but less so)!?!? (I just find it challenging to make these helpful messages stick). Apparently what is helping me the most is no longer as widely accepted in psychology circles, or so it appears to me. Bah!!!! I'm helped more by things that increasingly popular theory says "should" make me worse!? What the ...? Oh well, never was much for the "mainstream" I guess.

I wonder if various competing theories simply go in and out of vogue as theorists notice more people having issues in specific directions, probably due to cultural changes and differences in parenting and school systems over time. The problem is, all these competing theories will do some good to some people ... to heavily paraphrase Lincoln, you can't use one model to treat all of the people all of the time. Perhaps what works best for a 40-something like me is not what works best for a 20-something today? The cultural landscape can change a lot in 20 years. What do you think?

For me, I don't pay attention to these "books" & panels of psychologists, etc. They're all basically picking at straws anyway.

Whatever works for ME is what is important. Perhaps it isn't the "new" or "in" thing -- but if it makes me feel better and able to cope more effectively, who cares? LOL

Like you said, no one is the same. We're all different. Take care & God bless. Hugs, Lee

Yeah, I am a lot like you. Generally, what is in vogue does not work well for me. I explain it to myself (and others) that I must be a classicist! The old tried and true methods work better for me than all that new stuff. I have tried a lot of the in vogue methods you listed and, while they make a lot of sense on paper, in the long-term I grew tired of the daily struggle to keep them up. My issues were just too heavy and after a while, I got emotionally worn out. I am now back in talk therapy and, while it's not perfect, there have been some results. It seems that, with me, a lot of therapy will generate only moderate results. It's difficult to accept that but that's my reality, no use fighting it. All the best to you!

Is there any way you could give us some titles of books that HAVE worked for you? I am in the second camp of books as well, the camp becoming less popular. I am curious how to get a hold of my emotional life as well, thanks!!!

I would have to agree with Leed-- find what works for you best

Humans do not fit in a nice square box-- meaning even the therapy treatments may work wonders for someone with the same dx as you, but may not work so great for you

We are individuals after all

What works for you works for you, and the heck to the other things that are not helpful to you!! I don't know what to say about the culture.