American Idol.. I cant believe it!!!!!!!!!

Personally, I think Melinda is the better of the two. I would pay to see her sing in concert. I wouldn't with Jordin, not yet anyway.

BUT I think Jordin will appeal to the younger audience and who, but theses kids, will sit there and vote 100 times for their favorite?

I will be shocked if Blake moves forward, not because I don't think he is talented but I think the other two are just better singers.

But, all those teeny-bopper votes that went to Sanjaya have to go somewhere...

hahaha yep

personally i think jordon should win....... i really like her voice..... yeah shes young but still very talented..... i think she deserves to win

My husband and I think Melinda is awesome.
Jordin is very good, but needs a little more seasoning, which will come with time,which she is so very close.
Blake did really well last night, I feel it may be Blake that stays and Jordin leaves, though I'm not a huge fan oof Blake, he's come a long way, where Jordin's song choices or whoever picked them, didn't help her.
So hard to decide between them all, but I feel Melinda deserves to win, she just has that kind of talent, that is so professional, makes one say, "Wow!"
We'll see tonite? Simon seemed nice last night, well, for him. ha!ha!

I knew the guy wouldn't last He was a bit quirky imo. I want Melinda... but Jordin is more worldly and younger, so they can groom her better and longer ... they are both great singers imo.

Who's it gonna b?

melinda waaaaaaaaa blake should have gone home!

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO MAN!!!! I can see it and yet I cant that Melinda got voted off. She just isnt as hip as the other two ... but yet a really great singer.. IDK but I think Blake is gonna win it next week. I might nad might not change my mind.. but I got a feelin.

I think Jordin will win it. I hope!

Even though I knew this might happen because she is not a pop singer that would appeal to the masses, I am still bummed Melinda went home. That girl can sing.

I'm in shock!! Pinch ME!!!! You know, I bet the majority thought Melinda was safe (enough votes) and she was accidentally voted off by 2nd place votes (I hope I made sense!)

i'm knocked out!

I am shocked also I thought Melinda would win for sure...she seemed to always be consistant.....but she will have a career somewhere
Snow

I can't believe Melinda got voted off. Blake is a novelty act, this year's Taylor. Jordin has been the judges' favorite for a long time.

I would pay to see Melinda in concert or buy her CD. I can't say that for the other two. I think that should be the criteria for voting, but what do I know.

Blake will probably win on the strength of the same teenybopper vote that subjected us to Sanjaya for so long.

Blake is the new 'Vote for the Worst' and all this time, I thought that web site quit with Sanjaya!!

I think it's ridiculous, that Melinda was sent home, what the hell is wrong with these people, don't they know talent??

Grrrrrrrrrrrrrr! I think she was best out of the 3.
I'm never going to allow myself to get hooked into watching the American Idol, it was hubby "the couch potato" that influenced me to, only nice thing, it was a time sitting down at the same time together.
Bah!!! Those who voted Melinda out, and also grow up. LOL!!

WOW!!!!!!!!!! I GOT A FLAME IN FRONT OF A POST I STARTED WOO HOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!

lol

I THINK I CAN SING NOW !!! LOLOLOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

hahahahaha

IDK. I do think Melinda can Sing!! However, sometimes she just seemed uncomfortable in the limelight, so meek. Alot of people might think,, how can someone so shy be an american idol. Often people want someone more assured to exude a star quality. I think Blake has that.. YET he did not have the talent that Melinda has. Jordin might have a bit of both. Just thoughts.. don't think im bashing Melinda, but I wasnt surprised that America didnt buy her as an idol, despite her awesome voice.