FAQ/Help |
Calendar |
Search |
Grand Member
Member Since Jul 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 581
19 |
#1
I think it's time we had a thread of reasons not to do it. We have a thread of other things to do, so we need Reasons Why You Shouldn't SI
__________________ ...she's a difficult girl...
Last edited by Christina86; Aug 31, 2009 at 01:11 AM.. Reason: added trigger icon for possible triggers |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken, Buffy01, CaptainKirk, TheNationalNobody
|
afterrain, AmandaBroken, anderson, Buffy01, CaptainKirk, Cutterfly, OreoQueen, Scout7, tealBumblebee
|
Poohbah
Member Since May 2005
Posts: 1,274
19 |
#2
Ok, Hmm..... reasons why not to?
1. Infections 2. Scars 3. Loss of blood 4. Friends and family around you get hurt 5. Death or hospital 6. Waste of time 7. Stealing (Like sharp objects that don't belong to you) 8. It's not easy to hide self harming </font><blockquote><div id="quote"><font class="small">Quote:</font> "Take care of your body and your body will take care of YOU." </div></font></blockquote><font class="post"> |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken, Buffy01, CaptainKirk, OreoQueen
|
AmandaBroken, anderson, Buffy01, CaptainKirk, IrinaWolfSoul, justgivealittle, lost13, LyricsThatSing, OreoQueen, tealBumblebee
|
Grand Member
Member Since Mar 2005
Location: Pennsylvania USA
Posts: 767
19 |
#3
reasons you should not.....
1. it is addicting 2. main one is you end up feeling worse and have to do it more to because of the shame and guilt over it. __________________ "My Therapist always says there is HOPE, so he continues to be my light of HOPE even on my darkest of days" |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken, anderson, AstroSpectrum, falsememory7, IrinaWolfSoul, November Blue, wottesworthgurl
|
Legendary
Member Since Jun 2003
Location: noplace
Posts: 10,284
21 132 hugs
given |
#4
That's a great idea! Anyone mind if we make it sticky?
For myself, I think that my main reason not to SI is still because I don't want to disappoint T. She told me that if I went home and cut, I would undo all of the work that we had done. I don't like that idea much. Other than that, I try to remember that SI doesn't fix anything. It avoids dealing with it for a little while, and creates bigger problems that I'll have to deal with eventually. Looking forward to the rest of your ideas. __________________ “We should always pray for help, but we should always listen for inspiration and impression to proceed in ways different from those we may have thought of.” – John H. Groberg |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken, OreoQueen
|
AmandaBroken, anderson, InTherapy, November Blue, Samdwich, smallbluefish
|
Grand Member
Member Since Jul 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 581
19 |
#6
Ok, my main reason not to is that it would let down a lot of people who trust me, and it would break that trust, and I would hate that. So... to keep trust.
__________________ ...she's a difficult girl...
|
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken, smallbluefish
|
Grand Member
Member Since Jan 2005
Location: Alabama
Posts: 787
19 |
#7
The reason I haven't cut in awhile is because it doesn't solve the problem. When I'd cut, it take my focus off the emotional pain and focus it on the physical pain. After the physical pain left, the emotional pain was still there and I had to deal with it. I've learned it's best to deal with the problem when it occurs rather than scar your body up over something that won't be a permanant fix.
__________________ ... What's this life for? |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken, November Blue
|
AmandaBroken, anderson, CantExplain, November Blue, smallbluefish, TaintedLove, tealBumblebee
|
Poohbah
Member Since May 2005
Posts: 1,274
19 |
#8
Emotional pain -> Physical pain-> Emotional pain [repeat]
It's a horrible circle repeating non stop. Just remember when self harming your not just hurting yourself, but also others around you! It's not good for you... |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken, TaintedLove
|
Grand Member
Member Since Jul 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 581
19 |
#9
Keep up the reasoning guys.
__________________ ...she's a difficult girl...
|
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken
|
Grand Magnate
Member Since Apr 2003
Location: Springfield Mo. USA
Posts: 3,501
21 |
#10
my kids would see my new marks and I would not be able to tell her why.. I would be ashamed of myself ..
I would have to tell my 3 year old why mommie could not pick her up __________________ |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken, falsememory7, hurting__, Lonewolf1992, smallbluefish, tealBumblebee
|
AmandaBroken
|
Poohbah
Member Since May 2005
Posts: 1,274
19 |
#11
It's isn't that much fun and makes you feel much worse.
|
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken
|
Guest
Posts: n/a
|
#12
I love that this thread is here. in the past i put simular ones on two other websites and on one it really took off, and the other continues in spurts.
One of my reasons is that if I continue my abuser wins. he felt all I was worth was to be his object to hurt and so on, my hurting myself is giving him what he wanted. |
Reply With Quote |
beutifulxdreamr
|
Legendary
Member Since Jun 2003
Location: noplace
Posts: 10,284
21 132 hugs
given |
#13
That is a good point. Why should you have to have to hurt yourself because somebody hurt you?
(which is a big one for me - I think I'll show them, but when you really think about it, does it make sense that you were hurt so now you should be hurt more?) __________________ “We should always pray for help, but we should always listen for inspiration and impression to proceed in ways different from those we may have thought of.” – John H. Groberg |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken
|
Junior Member
Member Since Aug 2005
Posts: 13
19 |
#14
Reasons not to SI:
It's addicting The scars don't go away Your kids will be confused (mine are) Your marriage could end ( mine did) You could lose custody of your kids (I did) It's much harder to date with scars that are hard to hide Even if you overcome what drove you to SI you still have the scars Your body is a gift. It's not very nice to reject that gift by abusing it. You become an easy target for people to judge you You have to listen to docs lecture you while being stitched. The ambulance, and cops can show up at your house in minutes and humilliate you in front of your whole neighborhood It's one step closer to suicide The devil will laugh at you It's easier to hate yourself If your kids catch you they will be traumatized and they will never forget it |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken, CantExplain, tealBumblebee
|
Veteran Member
Member Since Feb 2005
Location: Utter Confusion; 24/7
Posts: 419
19 |
#15
[[[[[[[[[[[[Tamzinrose]]]]]]]]]]]
I think you have a fantastic idea!!! The problem with this forum; is it seems like it's a "fad" for a week or so & then "poof" everyone's gone. I didn't appreciate that they cut my thread; but I don't understand a lot of things they do around here...despite guidelines..... But I think that a #1 Reason of WHY NOT to SI would be SCARS For most of us, it's summer -- cannot cover "those scars" SI-ing in intimate areas b/c they don't show, how are you going to explain them to your partner.....better yet -- Doctors -- There's a huge anti-stigma movement going on -- but there is very little info/help/stories of mistreatment like in ER's of SI ers How can I ever go back to nursing? The most recent cuts have me running a fever b/c I don't want to go to a doctor b/c of how I've been treated in the past (even w/ the nursing creditials)--if you're an SI-er -- you could be the Pope -- you're still treated like dirt!! Would ANYONE help me go up to bat as a spokesman for SIers? If not, I'll stay in my apt. & hide like the rest of you get infections and die w/o a reason/reason/purpose. Think about........my body can't take this & they just a small tumor near my eye orbital/brain area...I haven't had a good summer. Reason #2: Unsanitary/Infections=fevers=hospitalization How's that for a starting? DAYZEE9 __________________ "DIVERSITY: The art of thinking independently together" ---MS Forbes |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken
|
Grand Member
Member Since Jul 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 581
19 |
#16
Thank you dayzee and thanks everyone else. *HUGS* to all of you. Thanks for sharing.
dayzee, I think you're probably right. I think a lot of people on here would agree with you. I wouldn't really know though, because I've never had medical treatment, mainly because I'm scared of people's reactions. So yeah, dayzee. You're right. And that's not a good thing... __________________ ...she's a difficult girl...
|
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken
|
Grand Member
Member Since Jul 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 581
19 |
#17
But...to be totally honest, I don't really see a problem with SI for me at the moment. So I retract my reasons against it.
__________________ ...she's a difficult girl...
|
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken, Milystiles
|
AmandaBroken
|
Member
Member Since Dec 2004
Location: new england
Posts: 132
19 |
#18
Reasons not to - interesting thread - happens to be my homework from my T this week also - so let's see --
The scars - I agree, that's a biggy Shame - I would feel awful if my kids knew, I feel like others look down on us for it - why do something you are definitely NOT proud of - doesn't seem a healthy choice Not a healthy way to cope - hope to be a therapist someday, wouldn't want to think that's how my T copes Addiction - do I want to be addicted to anything? It's not any different from being addicted to alcohol, drugs, or overeating. An addiction is an addiction. Don't want to give my life over to that. Abuse - As someone else pointed out, why continue? why take over where your abuser left off? If I give in to abusing myself, I'm suggesting that his view of my selfworth was right. I don't want to give him that. Cycling - it was suggested that si fuels my depression which fuels my si - I need to break the cycle in order to feel better about myself and get out of this rut. I definitely want to stop feeling the way I do right now. I don't know how much longer I can last feeling this way. If stopping can change this feeling, then it would be worth it. That's all I can think of right now. It has helped though. I guess I'll have to keep looking at this post and remembering what I'm working for. Thanks, Quay |
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken
|
Grand Member
Member Since Jul 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 581
19 |
#19
Thank you too. Twas good posting.
__________________ ...she's a difficult girl...
|
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken
|
Junior Member
Member Since Sep 2005
Location: Georgia
Posts: 15
19 |
#20
-Because when you can say (and BELIEVE) that you are strong enough to not cut, it will feel way better than cutting ever did.
|
Reply With Quote |
AmandaBroken
|
AmandaBroken, beutifulxdreamr
|
Reply |
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
What are the reasons why you cut or self injure? | Self Injury | |||
26 Reasons What You Think is Right is Wrong | Other Mental Health Discussion | |||
37 Reasons It's Great To Be A Man | General Social Chat |