Home Menu

Menu


Reply
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #26  
Old Aug 10, 2016, 09:15 AM
WrkNPrgress WrkNPrgress is offline
Poohbah
 
Member Since: Dec 2014
Location: Here and Now
Posts: 1,158
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anonymous37827 View Post
Billy Connelly- a Fabulously effed up and brilliant Scottish comedian, and his therapist / wife Pamela. They're a wonderful couple. They may be the exception that proves the rule, but it proves that there are exceptions.
Can you find me a link that says she was his practicing psychologist when they met?

I've only read that they met on set of a television show (Not the Nine O'Clock News.) She is also a performer and a dancer who was previously married to an actor Connelly knew. So most likely they connected through their tv careers, NOT her peychology practice.

I haven't found anything to suggest this couple formed while he was a patient of hers. So no I don't see ANY reason to rationalize a patient/client relationship with this example.

advertisement
  #27  
Old Aug 10, 2016, 11:55 AM
frackfrackfrack frackfrackfrack is offline
Member
 
Member Since: Oct 2014
Location: US
Posts: 363
Quote:
Originally Posted by WrkNPrgress View Post
I'm sorry if this is inappropriate (or perhaps already discussed) but is it possible that your obsession with your T is deflecting from you making a decision about your real life relationship?

I know that for a while my Transference allowed me to escape a very unhappy relationship and imagine 'running away' with some one who seemed to fit the kindness and understanding I was hungry for. I finally made a decisions to leave my unhappy situation and although my Transference is still present, it's not nearly as powerful or desperate feeling and I can feel myself coming back to Me.

You have a right to be happy. What would happen if you focused on your real-life relationship instead of your T? Can you change something there that would better fit YOUR needs?
That's a fair question, and the truth is I don't know. I have asked myself this too. I've been attracted to my T for two years and during that time I did leave one unhappy relationship (it is what I went to therapy for originally). As I said above, sometimes I am unable to tell whether the problems I see in my relationship are because I am attracted to T or if they are there on their own. I do try o focus on my real-life relationship, what I cannot figure out how to do is to forget about him when I see him every week.The only thing I can think of is to stop therapy, and this is what I've been trying to figure out if I should do.
  #28  
Old Aug 11, 2016, 12:57 AM
WrkNPrgress WrkNPrgress is offline
Poohbah
 
Member Since: Dec 2014
Location: Here and Now
Posts: 1,158
Quote:
Originally Posted by frackfrackfrack View Post
... .The only thing I can think of is to stop therapy, and this is what I've been trying to figure out if I should do.
I feel like this is framed as very black and white when there may be other options.

Why is stopping the only alternative? Why not see someone else for a while? Perhaps a female, if that would deflect any transference issues?
  #29  
Old Aug 11, 2016, 06:58 AM
frackfrackfrack frackfrackfrack is offline
Member
 
Member Since: Oct 2014
Location: US
Posts: 363
Quote:
Originally Posted by WrkNPrgress View Post
I feel like this is framed as very black and white when there may be other options.

Why is stopping the only alternative? Why not see someone else for a while? Perhaps a female, if that would deflect any transference issues?
So you mean I mainly talk to the other therapist for a while to process my feelings about T?

You know, I am a little bit afraid that another therapist just won't "get it", all the things I've been feeling and going though re him and it will just feel worse.

Last edited by frackfrackfrack; Aug 11, 2016 at 07:23 AM.
  #30  
Old Aug 11, 2016, 01:16 PM
WrkNPrgress WrkNPrgress is offline
Poohbah
 
Member Since: Dec 2014
Location: Here and Now
Posts: 1,158
I can understand the fear. But it also might be possible a new perspective will help you get a grasp on this and see a healthier, happier way out of these feelings and needs that are not going to be met in your current situation.

Sometimes I feel like people look at their therapist like a gambler does at a bad hand. They think "I can't quit now, I've got all this time and energy 'invested' I have to make it work." So they keep throwing in more energy and more time into something that isn't giving them what they need.

It's seems clear to me that this current T is not helping you process these emotions well enough. There's a block there so much that you're thinking of quitting all together. You don't have to quit AND you DON'T have to continue with this person. None of your time and energy spent is wasted. What you have learned will carry onto the next therapist.

What matters most in all of this is that your emotional needs get met. This is why you went into therapy in the first place. It's YOUR treatment. YOU deserve better. You shouldn't have to quit the game because you got a bad team player. You just get a new team to work with. YOU have to take care of YOU.

If things are not progressing with you current T and it feels more painful that helpful, I'm suggesting taking a break from this one and find another therapist to whom you can talk these things out with. And yes, just to talk about this T or another T is not an unheard of thing. People do it sometimes because it's all 'grist for the mill'. It's a reasonable strategy and your feelings are worth it.

As far as the other T not getting it, I'd be surprised if you didn't find a more compassionate response than you would ever expect. Transference is a common thing in therapy and not all therapists handle it well. When/if you sit down with another therapist, you can explain to them what you need - in processing this experience with your current T- and I'm betting that other T will help you out a lot. he main point being that you won't feel bogged down sorting out your feelings for someone while trying to talk TO that someone. Switch up the dynamic a bit and get an alternate perspective. It may even be that new therapist has had similar experiences of their own to share.

Thanks for this!
frackfrackfrack, LonesomeTonight, rainbow8
  #31  
Old Aug 12, 2016, 08:12 AM
Lauliza's Avatar
Lauliza Lauliza is offline
Grand Magnate
 
Member Since: Nov 2009
Location: United States
Posts: 3,231
Quote:
Originally Posted by frackfrackfrack View Post
I don't think consciously he urges me. Maybe unconsciously, but I am not sure because he won't talk about his feelings, or just turns it on me and asks me what makes me feel that he is attracted. That makes me think that it's all in my head. Maybe it is.

How have you gone on so long working with your pdoc? Are you reaching any resolution to the transference? Are you aiming for that?

After I started dating and seeing somebody, maybe for a very short time, I felt my bf could keep my attention off of T, but it soon came back. I don't know if it is because this relationship is not right for me, or if it is just that I was already attracted to T and it would be hard for a real person to displace the fantasy I have of him.

He does care for me, but I don't think that's the reason he did not refer me. I think the reason is that in spite of any attraction, he thinks of me as any other client. he has his attraction under control and i don't think he feels anything for me emotionally. recently, he said something like it's as if I were to be attracted to a student who dissertation I was supervising (I am a professor). So I feel perhaps his attraction is not something that overwhelms him, and he thinks that he can function as my therapist. I once asked him how come his feelings seemed to be so easy for him to deal with compared to me, and he said "because it's my job". I think he is just a very practical, slightly unromantic sort of person.
I felt incredibly hurt and rejected in my own relationship when I first started seeing pdoc, so I think that had a lot to do with it. He is in my age range, divorced and very, very handsome, so I look back now and wonder- how could I not have been attracted to him under those circumstances? I showed friends his online dating profile and they reacted the same way. So the fact that I was probably just one of many who felt the same way helped me normalize it. I did talk to my therapist about it as well and she encouraged me to talk to him about it, which I did in a very roundabout way- no names. He was very non alarmist and basically had the attitude that it was normal to be attracted to people and that I should just enjoy it. He did ask however, if it was painful and if I wanted to stop "talking to this person". When I said no he told me to just take it for want it is, flirt a little and enjoy the attraction. It has helped me a lot because I don't feel as attracted in session-it's always stronger out of session which makes me think it's all about the fsntasy and not really him. A lot has happened in the years that I've seen him - my husband moved out twice and moved back in, I tried online dating and saw someone for a couple of months, struggled with an eating disorder, got my first job since staying home with my 3 kids, lost 20 pounds, I started and am almost finished with a masters in counseling, got a job in the field, moved. He's seen me through a lot. I actually think he was attracted to me at first, but I'm guessing. He seemed it but even if he was never would have told me, which I am grateful for. I think when Ts tell clients this it can mess with your head a little. And for me, even if he was I'm sure it disappeared after on of my many sessions where I give TMI . Sorrg if I'm rambling, but I guess the main thing that has helped me is time and the fact that my life is just fuller now- I'm not saying the attraction is 100% gone, it's not, but with so many other priorities it's not a major focus.
Thanks for this!
frackfrackfrack, LonesomeTonight, rainbow8
  #32  
Old Aug 12, 2016, 04:08 PM
frackfrackfrack frackfrackfrack is offline
Member
 
Member Since: Oct 2014
Location: US
Posts: 363
Quote:
Originally Posted by WrkNPrgress View Post
I can understand the fear. But it also might be possible a new perspective will help you get a grasp on this and see a healthier, happier way out of these feelings and needs that are not going to be met in your current situation.

Sometimes I feel like people look at their therapist like a gambler does at a bad hand. They think "I can't quit now, I've got all this time and energy 'invested' I have to make it work." So they keep throwing in more energy and more time into something that isn't giving them what they need.

It's seems clear to me that this current T is not helping you process these emotions well enough. There's a block there so much that you're thinking of quitting all together. You don't have to quit AND you DON'T have to continue with this person. None of your time and energy spent is wasted. What you have learned will carry onto the next therapist.

What matters most in all of this is that your emotional needs get met. This is why you went into therapy in the first place. It's YOUR treatment. YOU deserve better. You shouldn't have to quit the game because you got a bad team player. You just get a new team to work with. YOU have to take care of YOU.

If things are not progressing with you current T and it feels more painful that helpful, I'm suggesting taking a break from this one and find another therapist to whom you can talk these things out with. And yes, just to talk about this T or another T is not an unheard of thing. People do it sometimes because it's all 'grist for the mill'. It's a reasonable strategy and your feelings are worth it.

As far as the other T not getting it, I'd be surprised if you didn't find a more compassionate response than you would ever expect. Transference is a common thing in therapy and not all therapists handle it well. When/if you sit down with another therapist, you can explain to them what you need - in processing this experience with your current T- and I'm betting that other T will help you out a lot. he main point being that you won't feel bogged down sorting out your feelings for someone while trying to talk TO that someone. Switch up the dynamic a bit and get an alternate perspective. It may even be that new therapist has had similar experiences of their own to share.

I'll bring up the topic of trying a different therapist for a while with my T. I wonder why he didn't suggest it.

It's true that I might get a better response. That's what I was hoping for when I saw a different therapist for one session to help me decide about stopping with my T. When I spoke to him over the phone and he asked me what I was looking for help with I explained the situation and said that in addition to figuring out about stopping therapy I wanted some sort of validation for my feelings, for the sadness and pain it causes. But I don't think that I got that from him. When I said that I feel disturbed when I see signs of attraction from my T and that he does not want to talk about it, the therapist said that he thought my T had done nothing wrong and that he seemed to have his feelings under control. That my pain is basically because of my own thinking, nothing to do with him - that was the message I got.
  #33  
Old Aug 12, 2016, 06:43 PM
Lauliza's Avatar
Lauliza Lauliza is offline
Grand Magnate
 
Member Since: Nov 2009
Location: United States
Posts: 3,231
Quote:
Originally Posted by WrkNPrgress View Post

It's seems clear to me that this current T is not helping you process these emotions well enough. There's a block there so much that you're thinking of quitting all together. You don't have to quit AND you DON'T have to continue with this person. None of your time and energy spent is wasted. What you have learned will carry onto the next therapist.

What matters most in all of this is that your emotional needs get met. This is why you went into therapy in the first place. It's YOUR treatment. YOU deserve better. You shouldn't have to quit the game because you got a bad team player. You just get a new team to work with. YOU have to take care of YOU.

If things are not progressing with you current T and it feels more painful that helpful, I'm suggesting taking a break from this one and find another therapist to whom you can talk these things out with. And yes, just to talk about this T or another T is not an unheard of thing. People do it sometimes because it's all 'grist for the mill'. It's a reasonable strategy and your feelings are worth it.

As far as the other T not getting it, I'd be surprised if you didn't find a more compassionate response than you would ever expect. Transference is a common thing in therapy and not all therapists handle it well. When/if you sit down with another therapist, you can explain to them what you need - in processing this experience with your current T- and I'm betting that other T will help you out a lot. he main point being that you won't feel bogged down sorting out your feelings for someone while trying to talk TO that someone. Switch up the dynamic a bit and get an alternate perspective. It may even be that new therapist has had similar experiences of their own to share.

:sadhug:
I think talking to another T could be helpful in some circumstances. I was fortunate in that my feelings were for my psychiatrist, not my therapist, so I had someone to go to who was removed from the situation. Plus she was in the same practice so she knew him well. I didn't realize at the time how fortunate I was because this is difficult to process on one's own.

I think the reaction you received from the T you interviewed might not be unusual. T-shirts approach transference differently and some downplay it a lot. Unless a T trained at a psychoanalytic institute, which isn't very common, then they haven't received formal training in transference (programs do not have classes on transference). That means that Ts learn as they go and through supervision, making their experiences very subjective.

The other issue is that you're not dealing only with transference, but with normal feelings of attraction that aren't being reciprocated the way you'd like. That would be hard for a lot of people to work through in or out of therapy. How would you like to see this resolved? Attraction is attraction and lots of processing still may not affect how you feel. Unless you know what you want come from talking about it, another T might not be much more helpful.
Thanks for this!
frackfrackfrack, LonesomeTonight
  #34  
Old Aug 13, 2016, 12:42 PM
frackfrackfrack frackfrackfrack is offline
Member
 
Member Since: Oct 2014
Location: US
Posts: 363
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lauliza View Post
How would you like to see this resolved? Attraction is attraction and lots of processing still may not affect how you feel. Unless you know what you want come from talking about it, another T might not be much more helpful.
I think you make a very good point here, and this is the key, and what I am stuck on. What do I want?

If I am attracted, but I don't see him regularly, perhaps I could deal with it. What disturbs me is to see him, and be in a position where my feelings about him are used in therapy, but not really treated as feelings. (Of course this is true for practically everyone on this board.) Ok, second, what disturbs me is that I see his attraction sometimes, it gives me some sort of hope (maybe that we will agree to stop therapy and perhaps someday far in the future, if its the right thing for both of us then, we could meet under different circumstances) and then I crash when I see him online on the dating site, or if I don't see him there for several days, or he starts suppressing the signs that indicate his attraction. (E.g. it has happened that when I told him I see him feeling attracted, he will ask me how, and then in the next session, I see him consciously avoiding giving me those signals.)
Thanks for this!
Lauliza
  #35  
Old Aug 13, 2016, 02:48 PM
Lauliza's Avatar
Lauliza Lauliza is offline
Grand Magnate
 
Member Since: Nov 2009
Location: United States
Posts: 3,231
Quote:
Originally Posted by frackfrackfrack View Post
I think you make a very good point here, and this is the key, and what I am stuck on. What do I want?

If I am attracted, but I don't see him regularly, perhaps I could deal with it. What disturbs me is to see him, and be in a position where my feelings about him are used in therapy, but not really treated as feelings. (Of course this is true for practically everyone on this board.) Ok, second, what disturbs me is that I see his attraction sometimes, it gives me some sort of hope (maybe that we will agree to stop therapy and perhaps someday far in the future, if its the right thing for both of us then, we could meet under different circumstances) and then I crash when I see him online on the dating site, or if I don't see him there for several days, or he starts suppressing the signs that indicate his attraction. (E.g. it has happened that when I told him I see him feeling attracted, he will ask me how, and then in the next session, I see him consciously avoiding giving me those signals.)
I had the dating site experience with my psychiatrist and that is very hard. I kind of became consumed with whether or not he was active and therefore still looking. There were times when he'd hide his profile for a while, presumably because he was dating someone, and I'd get depressed. That really sucks so I can empathize with you.

The thing that would be hardest for me though, is the conflicting signals you seem to get. I got them but only before our "talk". After that they stopped 100%. No longer sessions, no more slightly flirty jokes. And it was ok, because somehow it wasn't an obvious change (it is now that I look back) - probably because I only see him once a month. Without that change I don't know that I would have been able to focus on my own life as much. Talking to my T helped too- it deflated the intensity and helped me give up the fantasy.

I think it's harder to let go if you keep getting little bits of encouragement, however, even if it's not intentional on his part. It seems like he may be naturally flirtatious and isn't aware of it until someone points it out - hence his suppression of certain behaviors after you point them out. I would maybe focus on how seeing him is affecting you emotionally outside of the therapy, because as far as I can see, what's bothering you isn't about therapy or him as a T. It's about spending all this time with someone you want but can't have. Maybe seeing another T, even at the same time, would be helpful. You need to decide what will be best for your emotional health and if you feel ready to address it.

Last edited by Lauliza; Aug 13, 2016 at 03:03 PM.
Thanks for this!
frackfrackfrack
Reply
Views: 3142

attentionThis is an old thread. You probably should not post your reply to it, as the original poster is unlikely to see it.




All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:00 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® — Copyright © 2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.




 

My Support Forums

My Support Forums is the online community that was originally begun as the Psych Central Forums in 2001. It now runs as an independent self-help support group community for mental health, personality, and psychological issues and is overseen by a group of dedicated, caring volunteers from around the world.

 

Helplines and Lifelines

The material on this site is for informational purposes only, and is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment provided by a qualified health care provider.

Always consult your doctor or mental health professional before trying anything you read here.