Home Menu

Menu


Closed Thread
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #76  
Old Nov 17, 2012, 10:45 PM
rainbow8's Avatar
rainbow8 rainbow8 is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: US
Posts: 13,284
Quote:
Originally Posted by just_some_girl View Post
I can see that you're hurting, Rainbow. Have just got to your thread now.

I don't know that I have anything useful to say... I agree with what farmergirl says here, but I think in my mind what needs to be adressed is why you continue to ruminate over T, not the fact that you do. I think the key is getting to the nature of these feelings, the nature of the 'shame', the obsession... the 'love' you feel for her.
I agree. I think we've come to the conclusion it's about not getting my needs met by my Mom, or being a preemie, or both. It's about attachment, wanting my T to be there for me in ways she can't, like my Mom was, or wasn't.
I appreciate what it is like to feel 'stuck', to be frustrated with something, confused and hurting. I admire your courage in continuing to post and reach out for support and help processing your feelings - especially when getting met with a certain air of 'here we go again'. Thing is Rainbow, I'd be willing to bet we're all ruminating about therapy or our therapists to some degree - some of us maybe more than we care to admit - otherwise, why would we be frequenting this forum, and why would we all continue to keep reading your threads? I don't think you're the only one searching for these kinds of answers. You're not the only one who's 'stuck' in some kind of 'pattern', either - though I'm not sure why you're one of those who gets called out on it while others are treated with kid gloves.
You're brave to post this! Thanks. I don't know why either but I have to accept the way it is for me, or choose to stop posting. Yes. Why do so many people have a need to discuss therapy? I find it interesting to do so--all aspects of therapy interest me, in addition to my own situation. It's fascinating, a world of its own. But yes, others ruminate too.
Anyway! I believe you DO want to change, that you WANT things to change - you just don't know how (yet!). But, again, a lot of the focus always seems to be on YOU changing YOUR behaviours - which, okay, yes, perhaps needs to be looked at - but I feel like the important thing is getting to the WHY. WHY you feel the way you do. WHY you ruminate. WHY you obsess. I'm not sure what if anything is being done to address that - in therapy or otherwise... am I wrong in saying that? I feel that, like with other things, if the core issue is addressed, the behaviours will likely take care of themselves. The behaviours are a symptom. Like SI, like comfort eating...
I changed Ts because my former one wouldn't let the child parts have their say. With this T, they have come out clear and strong that they want to be loved. That's the why, I think. I keep asking my T Why and she says, like the others said, it's 'unmet needs from the past. Your Mom and you didn't fit right. Etc." I've always wanted to know the why and it's been frustrating. Why I'm never satisfied, why I feel disappointed, why I can't get myself to quit therapy, why I obsess about T. Why I'm so messed up. It's a combination of things. Everyone's life is complicated. It's my brother. It's my genetic tendency towards shyness. It's the lack of expressing feelings in my family. It's whatever caused my selective mutism and BPD. I don't think I can get to the core anymore than that. I've tried. So WHAT do you think is my core issue? I'll have to ask T but she'll probably say 'attachment difficulties" due to my infancy and childhood, and my Mom's over attachment.
You say that you have had these strong feelings for each T you've had - were they all female? I wonder if you'd have the same issue with a male T. I wonder if the feelings come about because of the nature of therapy, or because it is an intimate relationship with a woman? I wonder what kind of transference this might be.
Yes, my Ts have all been female. My guess is that it would be MORE sexual feelings with a male.
I'm not surprised you feel that T embarassed you... I think any of us would feel embarassed to some extent if our Ts asked us about our feelings and reactions to them, to their touch, if it was 'crossing over' or 'arousing' or if the connection felt sexual in some way. But it really did seem to hit a nerve with you. I think what you need to explore, again, is why.

You have skirted around whether you think you're in denial - about your sexuality? Maybe this issue needs to be explored... but it may not even be about that. Perhaps it is something else about emotional intimacy. Perhaps it is a craving for something maternal.

I've been reading a book called 'In Session: The bond between women and their therapists' - I wonder if you've read it? There is something in there about the 'golden fantasy'... I think it would be a good read for you.

I've read In Session and it's excellent. I'm glad you've read it too. Yes, emotional intimacy, to me, has always been more important than sexual intimacy. It's what I want. I don't know if it's maternal or what. It's about feeling safe, usually, but there's the "in love" aspect too. Thanks for your support and helpful observations and questions. I wish we all weren't so complicated and could fill out questionaire and get all the answers. Would be nice, huh!
Hugs from:
Anonymous33425

advertisement
  #77  
Old Nov 17, 2012, 10:48 PM
SallyBrown's Avatar
SallyBrown SallyBrown is offline
Poohbah
 
Member Since: Jul 2011
Posts: 1,422
Quote:
Originally Posted by rainbow8 View Post
I think I said people don't like me, not that they "hate" me. I said "I hate PC". That was because I feel so bad when I don't get what I want. Yes, that's a pattern in my life. A huge one. I'm disappointed in therapy, I'm disappointed on here, and I'm disappointed by people in RL often. I didn't know how to get more responses, and I wanted them. The hurting part wanted them. I don't KNOW how to get attention in a positive way. If I ask "could I have more responses, please?" won't people think I'm selfish? I can't think of a productive way to word it. People will call me a narcissist again. I feel stuck!
Things I have seen people do to get their threads read:

1. Write a "bump" post, along the lines of, "Bumping this thread, really stuck and hoping for more responses!"
2. Write on the couch that they're hoping for more responses to their thread, so could people take a look if they have a chance?
3. Write a PM (of course, to me, since I only read PMs to me, but this could work between any set of PC "buddies") asking someone who they know might have something to say about their particular topic to give a quick response if they can.

Do you honestly think that asking directly and politely for feedback is MORE selfish than saying, "I hate PC"? Attempting to hurt an entire group of people -- indiscriminately, at that, so including people who have tried really hard to support you -- using hurtful language in order to get what you want is one of the most selfish things a person can do. That's why I didn't respond to it immediately. I'm not going to reward that kind of behavior. You don't get to hurt me in order to get your way.

Why I didn't respond the first time:

1. I didn't have a set of complete thoughts to articulate.
2. Can't I see you're hurting? Yes, I can. I can see that EVERYONE ON THIS FORUM is hurting. *I* am hurting. Your pain is no more or less important than anyone else's, so we can all either respond to every single thread, or we can restrict our responses to those for which was have something thoughtful to add. The latter seems more feasible to me.
3. I've had a really really busy work week.
4. My therapy situation currently has me in a state of grief that makes me generally slow to post.

That you might POLITELY request more feedback would not make you selfish. That you act as if not getting immediate non-critical feedback means that everyone here is terrible for not acknowledging YOUR pain RIGHT NOW when we all have our own lives, struggles, opinions, and yes, our own pain, is really selfish.

I am not trying to hurt you. I recognize that none of these things are fun to hear. But if you really want answers, here they are.
Thanks for this!
anilam, rainbow8, Sila
  #78  
Old Nov 17, 2012, 11:06 PM
rainbow8's Avatar
rainbow8 rainbow8 is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: US
Posts: 13,284
I'm going out of order to respond to you. Hope it's not confusing.
Quote:
Originally Posted by 2or3things View Post
My observation is that people will support you in your efforts toward change. Maybe not. Maybe they are in it to understand and learn about themselves, to learn to express feelings, to learn to sing in therapy, to learn to accept T's caring, and so on. Maybe it's to have someone who validates them and listens to them. Maybe it's because they need to learn how to calm down and meditate.(That's why most people are in therapy, no?) I think the frustration comes in when you demand attention and support for your current state, but that current state seems no different than where you were at last month or last year. It often seems to me like you have many excuses...You just started DBT, this is your first experience with SE, you may have been in therapy for X number of years, but most of them didn't count because you had trouble talking, you didn't want to email your T, but you couldn't help it, etc.
My current state IS different from last month or last year. I know that and don't have to prove it. Those above are valid reasons. I AM trying to change. I'm less anxious. That's important to me. I've started drawing again. That's major! It's insulting to me for you to tell me I haven't changed when you don't even KNOW me.
In all honesty, it feels incredibly manipulative. Sort of like saying "Well, I can't really change (because I don't really want to and always find an excuse not to), but you should all feel bad for me anyway. And if you don't, you're just mean."

Bottom line, we're all struggling to get it right, and I know as much as anyone that it's not easy. I don't think it does you any good for anyone to say "Oh, Rainbow...it's OK that you did X for the 100th time." Because really, it's not. When you know better, you're supposed to do better. When you ask for support for things you've done directly in opposition to your healing, why on earth would people tell you it's OK? I mean, we all slip up from time to time, but it feels like a little bit of a farce coming from you at this point.
I'm sorry but I am going to stand up for myself this time. You don't know what I'm doing in my life outside of therapy, only what I post. It's only your opinion, not the truth. Not MY truth.
I really do say this in the spirit of loving honesty, not harshness, though I know it may be difficult to hear.
It comes across as harsh but I will believe you that you don't mean it that way since you say so.
My best to you.
  #79  
Old Nov 17, 2012, 11:51 PM
2or3things's Avatar
2or3things 2or3things is offline
Member
 
Member Since: May 2011
Location: turns out it really doesn't matter
Posts: 328
First, it seems to me that all the things you cite above are examples of change.

Second, you're right. None of us know you or what you're doing in your non PC life. We only have the image and thoughts you present. Still, you asked for feedback regarding the things you DO report. I'm sorry you don't like what I have to say, though I say it in response to what you've originally written. In any case, I stand by all I've said. All any of us has to go on is what we see in your posts, and I haven't made a bit of it up.

Further, given that this isn't the first time you're hearing this particular comment from a PC member, I can't imagine why you'd want to leave out all the wonderful progress you're making. Are you trying to make your situation sound worse than it is for sympathy or so that you can still get the support you seek even though you've improved? Is it something else? (It's not that I really believe this, but it's curious to me that you wouldn't want people to know how well things are going when they do. I get the need for privacy, if that's the issue, but I wouldn't think that'd it'd be any more difficult to maintain privacy regarding the good stuff than the difficult stuff.)

Third, just about every time anyone says anything about you that you don't like, you play the "I'm going to stand up for myself" and "You don't know me" cards. Fine, but again, I still see what I see in your writing. And I see these as further ways that you're trying to convince yourself that you're making big strides or that you don't really need to change or whatever it is you're interested in having people reflect back to you without dissent. It seems to me as though you have difficulty taking responsibility for your trouble ("I couldn't help it," "I don't know how to do that," etc.). But when someone confronts you about your role in perpetuating your problems, and then you suddenly get very assertive and talk about all the hard work you've done. Then it's lather, rinse, repeat.

As I said, I know it's hard. I'm living it too, as are many of us here. I know that I'm frustrated with the pace of my own progress. I'm confused about whether you're proud of all yours or whether you feel it's hopeless and out of your control. Or maybe it's something else that you haven't revealed to us?

I assume you'll respond to this the way you responded to my previous post. (As you know, you're always free to take or leave any and all advice--and posters--here.) My biggest wish for you, however, is that you could take some of these types of responses in, as I think taking your own power back is the only way you can have the life you say you want.

Again, my best to you. No one is perfect...we're all just doing the best we can. And honestly, I'm actually trying to help.
Thanks for this!
rainbow8
  #80  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 12:41 AM
adel34 adel34 is offline
Grand Member
 
Member Since: May 2012
Location: Chicago IL
Posts: 800
Just found this thread tonight. Yesterday we lost power where I live and so I wasn't on the computer.
I have mixed feelings about all this. As I commented in another of Rainbow's threads, having gone back and read a bunch of stuff I can see where some of it sounds the same even from years ago and how that can be frustrating. But I also see changes. I don't think Rainbow would have been open to DBT back in 209 when she first got here, and she's actively working in a group now. I wish she would post about the positive things that are going on, so we can see her progress more, and know that though it's still a struggle things are getting better.
I personally hit the "thanks" button to acknowledge when anyone has posted on my thread, so they know I received it. Then when I have time I usually try to go back and respond. I do also try and hit the "hugs button" whenever I can as well, as I think hugs are really helpful. I can't imagine this forum without those buttons, and wonder how it was decided to put them in or whatever.
__________________
Check out my blog:
matterstosam.wordpress.com
and my youtube chanil:
http://www.youtube.com/user/mezo27
Thanks for this!
rainbow8
  #81  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 09:24 AM
rainbow8's Avatar
rainbow8 rainbow8 is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: US
Posts: 13,284
Quote:
Originally Posted by Miswimmy1 View Post
I am sure you are hurting and my heart goes out to u. Really.
Thank you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Miswimmy1 View Post
I am going to respectfully disagree with this comment. I don't know if it makes any difference that I am 15, but some would argue that 15 is too old as well. I totally disagree. If you're hurting in life, or you are lonely, anything helps. I would have made this comment myself, until I was in a hard place. And those hugs were what literally kept me going. It's amazing what a virtual hug can do...
I agree with you. Thanks for your support.

Quote:
Originally Posted by healed84 View Post
Rainbow.. Have you considered that your T is just wrong?? Maybe why you are so bothered for it. Just b/c you T got a sense, or saw a crossing over of emotions, doesn't mean she is right. You have said yourself that you didn't feel it, you weren't aroused, or thinking of sexual things.
She could be wrong. I'm confused about it.
As far as feeling ignored.. I think sometimes people don't respond b/c they simply do have any good advice. Or maybe they are triggered, or whatever. Are you too senstive to be on the board? Only you can answer that.. I think that there maybe some people who should avoid certain boards or topics b/c it will trigger them.
Thanks. I know my T would prefer I not be on this forum so much. I'm going to discuss with her how I can do that. Just to PMs maybe. I don't want to give up PC completely.

Quote:
Originally Posted by hankster View Post
MUE can use that in her comedy act tonight, that somebody thought I could be the nice one

Rainbow, TOTALLY been there done that with the embarrassment in T. It helped me when T got embarrassed, but boy, talk about your major rupture. But that is why things are good between us, because there is no more possible embarrassment. Well, no, I take that back - it does wear off after a while; but no, there is nothing wrong with being totally embarrassed in T. That's actually what we go there for, I think. It means we're touching something meaningful.
Thank you.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lycanthrope View Post
Not to derail the thread but when I start a thread I much prefer insight, even if it's something I might not like to read or perhaps even disagree with. Hugs and thanks are easy to do, just a click of a button but giving a differing view of things, so we can maybe see things from a different perspective, is what a forum likes this is about. If we all just clicked the hugs and thanks button and didn't reply with posts this forum would be pointless. Just asking for thanks and hugs looks like the poster is attention seeking, and doesn't want to read any opinion through fear of it challenging their behaviour.
I never said I just wanted hugs or thanks. You misunderstood me. I didn't want to be ignored.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lycanthrope View Post
If somebody wants to give a hug they can. That's up to them. All I'm saying is that the hugs doesn't really help but what can help is people posting and giving a different perspective on things. Also if someone makes a post and is afraid of negative responses, an easy cop out is to ask for hugs and thanks for sympathy. It validates the OP, in their mind all these hugs and thanks means they're correct and all the posters who might comment will back off because they don't want to look nasty, or come across as controversial or bullying. So in otherwords the entire thread is derailed into a lovefest with no real insight. Just my opinion, the hugs button doesn't mean anything, most forums don't have hugs buttons and this forum survived and several years without it.
You have a point. It's both. The hugs help when there's no time to write or you don't know what to say. I send a lot of 'hugs' because I want the OP to know I care and that I read their thread even if I may not post in it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Miswimmy1 View Post
And this is what I am disagreeing with. Hugs do help for some. No one is *obliged* to give them. but they can hav a positive impact for some ppl.

And i agree with you that constructive insight can sometimes be more beneficial. I am not aruging with that, or about the fact that this forum is not built solely on the hug and thanks button. Its not. I am only saying that this user asked for hugs, obviously feels that they would be beneficial to them. So therefore, hugs can help
I agree, Miswimmy.
  #82  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 09:28 AM
rainbow8's Avatar
rainbow8 rainbow8 is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: US
Posts: 13,284
Quote:
Originally Posted by mixedup_emotions View Post
((( Rainbow )))

I can understand you feeling embarrassed and upset. But I agree that your T isn't the one that embarrassed you. One needs to take ownership of their own feelings, although it's true that someone's actions can help one feel a certain way.

It seems to me that you're upset because you felt so embarrassed that you weren't able to really assess what you were truly experiencing at the time. It's ok that you weren't able to. It ends up being something worth exploring on a couple of levels....

One, the idea that when struck with embarrassment, you disconnect.

Two, exploring whether or not her feedback fit for you or not (and it seems that it may not have fit)...and see where that leads.

(( HUGS ))
These are good points, MUE. Thank you for posting to me here and for the hugs.
  #83  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 09:29 AM
Anonymous35535
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
"If I were to try to read, much less answer, all the attacks made on me, this shop might as well be closed for any other business. I do the very best I know how - the very best I can; and I mean to keep doing so until the end. If the end brings me out all right, what's said against me won't amount to anything. If the end brings me out wrong, ten angels swearing I was right would make no difference." ~ Abraham Lincoln

My therapist told me that it took Mr. Lincoln thirty-two failures before his law practice became successful. She was trying to get me to see that I shouldn't give up on our relationship (therapy) changing me. It took three therapist and three years to heal our family. The first two years and two therapist were nightmares. With my own life I probably had twenty tries over the decades, and I saw myself as a failure unwilling to change. I was doomed to stay miserable, and she sure as heck wasn't going to be able to FIX me. Voila! I have never felt better in my life, sustained happiness - no medications. My therapist wants to hit the roots of my issues, and that means gads of pain. It just occurred to me that we do this work with touch and that maybe the difference in the rate of my healing, with no numbing drugs. And so I am able to live a healthier life - quicker recovery or no need to recover because I've handled it successfully. Even when I fail it's okay. She doesn't particularly care for me to read PC, because of the way it affects me sometimes. This has been going on for six months. She doesn't berate me when I've slipped, and embraces me till I heal.

My whole point Rainbow8 is: Don't Give Up! Change can take many failures before it really happens. All my best as you wade through the process.
Thanks for this!
rainbow8
  #84  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 09:33 AM
Anonymous200125
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Quote:
Originally Posted by rainbow8 View Post



I never said I just wanted hugs or thanks. You misunderstood me. I didn't want to be ignored.
The hugs button is an easy way for a poster to ignore your posts. You made a load of lengthy replies on this thread, I haven't bothered to read them all, but I could send you a hug on every post you've made if you like to pretend that I care and I've read all your posts. It's an easy way for someone to click a button and not actually bother to read any of your posts. So it may make you feel better by asking for hugs and receiving but don't think it necessarily means much to posters that give the hug. It's a click of a button. Some may mean it of course but don't think just because someone gives you a cyber hug it's means they're not ignoring you.
Hugs from:
Anonymous35535, EeyoreSmile
  #85  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 09:40 AM
Anonymous200125
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Quote:
Originally Posted by stopdog View Post
I am not a big believer in others deciding what someone else needs or needs to do or should do, or what is in someone else's best interest or for their own good.
That's fine. But don't start a thread asking for help because that's what people do. They recommended what you need to do or should do. If you start a thread asking for help then you will be advised what to do in that situation based on that persons experience on what they would do. Or we could just spam the forum with 1000's of these
  #86  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 09:45 AM
rainbow8's Avatar
rainbow8 rainbow8 is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: US
Posts: 13,284
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anne2.0 View Post
Rainbow, just a first reaction to this post and the ones that preceded it. I say this as gently as possible in writing-- you need to confront and deal with your need to see the "attention" and other things that people give you as perpetually deficient. You do get responses, every time you post a thread, you are NOT ignored. Certainly you realize the lack of logic-- suggesting that emotions rule-- in posting AFTER people have responded to say you're being ignored?
Anne, please look back at page one. I had 2 responses, from hankster and farmergirl. Then I saw the "thanks" to fg (there weren't as many as now) with no hugs or reponses to me, and I got triggered. I should have been more patient but I was afraid my thread would disappear and I was feeling bad about the issue in my session. I still am, but am living with those feelings until Tuesday.
Pema Chodron has a new book (or at least new this year) and she references what I think is an amazing book written by a brain researcher who had a stroke (My Stroke of Insight). She studies the neurobiology of emotion, and she reported that the life of an emotion (in the brain itself, from trigger to where the brain lets it go) is 90 seconds. So if you get angry, that emotion does its neurological cycle and is over after 90 seconds. If it's lasting longer, then we're doing something to reactivate it, like pouring gasoline on a fire. I've found this concept to be really useful for me lately. If I notice what I'm feeling, I attend to it, maybe think about what it's about, try to drop the "storyline" (typical interpretation about what it means), I find it goes on its way and leaves me alone. I can usually wait out those 90 seconds.
90 seconds. I will try that! thank you.
But, going back to your T, that piece of how you felt that she left you thinking about sex and feeling shame, that seems like it doesn't belong to you. Or your T. That seems to belong to your brother. It just sits squarely on my CSA bones, if that makes any sense.

Not your shame, that is what was put upon you. And you feeling (not acting) sexual towards anyone is not anything that any of us can control. Shame is not something that we are born with, with respect to sexuality. Anyone who's had a kid knows that kids are NOT ashamed of their bodies, quite the opposite, shame about our bodies and feeling good is what is put upon us.

It's taken me a long time, but I think of my lust (my word for feeling sexual towards someone) as something that is really important to me. I like to count on my lust. I like to know that if I am still lusting, I am still pretty much alive. Even though I've been married a long time, sometimes my more subtle feelings for my H wax and wane, but I can always count on my lust. And before I was married, people came in and out of my life, but my lust was always with me. I guess I'm saying that lust, feeling sexual, is a healthy and very human response. Lust isn't the problem, feeling sexual towards someone, T or not, isn't the problem. It's what we think people do about with their lust (what we've been taught people do, or what we've watched people do) that's the problem, and that's what people often have something to be embarrassed about, not the feelings themselves.
Thank you for sharing all the above.
I think this incident with your T has brought up something very important for you to work on, and it seems to go back to your brother, and the aftereffects of that. I'm just really sorry that you had to experience that growing up, and that you have to heal from it now. But you are really on your way, don't give up.
Thank you again, Anne. I will try not to give up, but when others tell me I haven't made progress, it makes me depressed and I DO feel like giving up. I will remember that you see me as changing and working hard. I'm going to ask my T too. I know she's not giving up on me, and sees changes.
  #87  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 10:00 AM
Anonymous32516
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
This is not a judgemental or critical post and since I can deal with someone thanking and others critising my writing on the forum Iīll have a go.

I have stated before and will do this again. You have on numerous occasions admitted to being " addicted" to T and this forum. I am not in anyway saying that you should leave T or not post in here, who am I to judge.
I have just " a tiny" proffesional insight in these sort of behaviours and I question why itīs not really that obvious to others to.

I really do think as YOU have stated yourself that you are more addicted to attention, hugs, unconditional love and not having to give that much in return than anything else. You get frantic and lash out if you donīt immediately " get your drug". One can call that a need to " get filled up" because you can not do that yourself.

This is trulely not a meant to be a harsh post but I truely believe you should focuse more on IRL and skills than hits and replies in here.Your T, your ex.T ( as I recall) and your DBT t donīt think you should ruminate inhere. You write Maybe they donīt like it? ( You know that already) Again itīs just like reading how an alcholic defend themselves and react when confronted.
I take the liberty of writing this because as I said you have mentioned " being addicted several times"before...and that you hate this addiction. I think after giving it some thought that it is a key issue and why people get a bit frustrated with the same behaviour over and over again. I really do acknowledge your pain. Whatever it comes from itīs pain.Just my tiny input. And just to say that I read your post a little bit different because I feel like there is something real important to adress other than the email and handholding discussions.
Also I can understand you may be a bit embarressed about what your T said but actually you have been writing alot about your se...al feelings towards your T inhere, in details. To the point of triggering people on the forum. Now we have to feel sorry for you for her mentiong it in session? You do get distressed and have a " fit" if she doesnīt want to hold your hand or get you a hug too.Does not make total sence to be honest.

Last edited by Anonymous32516; Nov 18, 2012 at 10:17 AM.
Thanks for this!
rainbow8
  #88  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 10:09 AM
rainbow8's Avatar
rainbow8 rainbow8 is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: US
Posts: 13,284
Quote:
Originally Posted by stopdog View Post
I am not a big believer in others deciding what someone else needs or needs to do or should do, or what is in someone else's best interest or for their own good.
I appreciate that comment, stopdog.

Quote:
Originally Posted by CantExplain View Post
Therapy does hurt. Ts have to break through the denial and let you see the truth. That's always painful.
That's true, but how do we know what the truth is? I realize I deny a lot, but I also don't trust my feelings so it's confusing.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jaybird57 View Post
My thoughts on this, Rainbow, is that your therapist might have made the mistake of stating HER interpretation of the situation before first diving in and exploring what you felt. I'm not saying that you would have been able to recognize any erotic/sexualized feelings, especially because this area seems so sensitive and shameful to you, but it might have given her a better reading on what was going on for you "in the moment" if she had explored this a bit before stating what "she" felt was happening.

Perhaps your therapist misread the moment. Heck, that happens! Our therapist's are human and don't always get it right . . . hence the term, countertransferance. All therapists would like to believe that they have a firm and steady hand on their countertransference feelings, but reality is, those feelings are slippery little suckers and they misinterprete all the time. I hope that you and your therapist are able to work this through!
Thank you. Yes, T could have misread the moment but I think she is right that sexual feelings are sometimes there in the room, but not when she's thinking they are. So she's right that we have to mindful about the touching.

Quote:
Originally Posted by tigergirl View Post
rain she seemed to be more concerned that you were trying to get your needs for human comfort (non-sexual or sexual I'm not sure) from her instead of your H ... maybe you need to focus on that more? and then the wanting hugs here seems to be an extension of that .... Yes, I want both kinds of comfort but she was talking about the sexual part at the time. I'm still triggered by the way she said it. It makes me cry right now.
nothing unusual about this ... or uncommon since so many of us are comfort starved ... but your t is the one person you are paying to help you get that need met through your h and through people other than her .... so calling you out on this was to try and help you ... isn't that part of why you are in therapy?
Yes, but she also used the touch last week in our work, and it was fine. She and I know I have to get my needs met by others. You're right; that is what she's there for. I feel a lot of shame about what she told me. It makes me want to disappear.
Quote:
Originally Posted by LolaCabanna View Post
in response to a question Rain asked...

I can understand not wanting your thread hi jacked, but to reprimand people for NOT liking or hugging or commenting on your thread? Or getting upset they liked what someone else said? We all gather support through each other, various ways. Be it via others comments, OP threads etc. We in turn respond to those people with thanks or hugs or additional comments. People create threads to share their stories or look for advice or to get a nod of understanding from someone going through the same situation. I think a good thread evolves into a round table discussion that will help the OP as it may help others. But comments like the one above lead me to believe that your intention when creating a thread is to have everyone stop what they are doing and respond to and acknowledge only you and only what you have to say.... and ,I am not trying to be mean here, but can you not see where it makes you come off a little selfish and entitled? PC is a team sport. It only works if we all play together.
Thanks, Lola. I do see what you're saying but to me, it looked like my "critics" were at it again, and I was being attacked with no one supporting me. I use the "thanks" button too, but it often seems to me, especially in my threads, that there are 2 sides: my critics and my supporters. The critics thank each other and that feels like a knife in my heart. I'm not saying it's accurate, and maybe it IS selfish, but those are my feelings. It seems like a war to me and I don't have the strength for it. I am going to have to figure out how to think differently next time so I don't get triggered, and to accept the criticism. Accepting criticism is hard.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Antimatter View Post
Okay, so maybe I am a bleeding-heart liberal here but I believe that behaviors occur for a reason and that the way to reducing the behaviors is to find the root cause. Getting stuck and reenacting the past over and over is not a place I would want to be (been there, am there sometimes), and rainbow, I truly feel for you. I am sad that you have been unable to yet find your way to peace.

My wish for you is that you could find validation and acceptance within yourself (also a wish for me). You deserve to be kind to yourself, you deserve to accept yourself. Best of luck on your journey.
Thank you, antimatter. I wish you the best of luck on your journey too, and hope you find peace and acceptance too.
Hugs from:
Anonymous35535
  #89  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 10:19 AM
Anonymous32910
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
"I had 2 responses, from hankster and farmergirl. Then I saw the "thanks" to fg (there weren't as many as now) with no hugs or reponses to me, and I got triggered. I should have been more patient "

You were definitely lacking in the patience department as there was only one hour between your initial post and your post chiding all of us for ignoring you. You had received two responses and had responded yourself twice so saying you were being ignored is a skewed and inaccurate perception. That's a pretty active thread as things go around here.

What is it about not being the center of attention that sets you off? Haven't you said you were your mother's center of attention most of the time (or am I thinking of someone else--sorry if I'm confused)? One thing you may need to learn is that expecting people to keep you at the center of attention is unrealistic and a wee bit self-centered (just being honest here). We aren't your mother, and your mother didn't do you any favors if that is what she did.

Your T isn't your mother either; she can't and won't see you as the center of her world. At some point, you have to be able to nurture yourself, validate yourself, stand as an independent entity by yourself rather than longing for a sort of enmeshment with your T because for some reason that seems to be the only way you feel safe and real. It's time to cut the apron strings with your mother, Rainbow. It's time to learn to feel safe and worthy as the independent woman that you can be rather than always looking for that security and validity in the eyes of your T or whomever you go to to make you feel recognized. NO ONE will ever be able to do that for you. You are seeking something from your T (and often from us here) that you really will never be able to find anywhere but within yourself.
Thanks for this!
2or3things, Anne2.0, pbutton, rainbow8
  #90  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 10:20 AM
rainbow8's Avatar
rainbow8 rainbow8 is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: US
Posts: 13,284
Quote:
Originally Posted by feralkittymom View Post
Being new here and not being familiar with a history, I really can't comment on the appropriateness of the thread, nor its intentions.

But responding to the session event, as it's been described, does bring up some thoughts. The therapy situation can be emotionally charged by definition. What the emotions are and how they're shown can vary from time to time. But examining how all those emotions resonate within both client and T can be valuable.

Ts can be highly observant and empathic. They can, and do, often sense feelings in us that we are not consciously aware of. In part, I think it's because of both their knowledge of how the mind works, and having examined themselves to know where their own sensitivities are and are not. This can allow them to be intuitive in an emotionally clear way. That's one version of counter transference. It's a benefit to us.

The other kind of counter transference comes from a sensitivity that the T is unaware of or has not resolved in themselves, and this is not beneficial to us.

I don't know if your T's "reading" of this experience as sexual was right or wrong. But it's possible that she is feeling a general emotional arousal in you, out of scale with what is going on in the therapy, and focused upon her, which is perhaps distracting from therapy.

That heightened emotional "pull" toward therapy and your T may be dysfunctional in that it could be resulting from an unhealthy, distracting need in you. And that may be the same need that some here are reacting to, as well.

With this sort of situation, the felt gratification of therapy and interaction with T becomes the focus of your attention--rather than self-understanding and discovery being central.

It's a fine line between getting formerly unmet needs met, and traumas addressed so that we can move on, and remaining in a child state of endless gratification to avoid moving on. The latter is often experienced by others as an inappropriate neediness.

A good T will be alert to this sensed perception, and will adapt so as to not continue to encourage that need. And will slowly try to bring it to a client's attention. Sometimes the client quits therapy at that point, or finds another T who may begin the "honeymoon" phase all over again. Sometimes, the client interprets these behaviors as a rupture. Sometimes, the client remains stuck.

And sometimes, client and T are a good enough match of readiness and expertise to use the experience productively. I hope this will be true for you.
Your post is insightful and relevant to my situation in therapy. You summed up the way therapy has been for me all of these years. It helps but I have gone from one T to another, still trying to get what they are unable to give me. I fit with my current T the best, and she has other techniques other than straight talk therapy, so I hope that she and I will be able to get through this to the other side. She is trying to build up my Self so that I do not have to rely on her. I have hopes that the DBT is going to help me, too. You say the traumas need to be addressed so we can move on. I've never been sure what my traumas are so maybe that's why I can't ever move on. I feel trapped in my own mess.
Hugs from:
Anonymous35535
  #91  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 10:25 AM
unaluna's Avatar
unaluna unaluna is offline
Elder Harridan x-hankster
 
Member Since: Jun 2011
Location: Milan/Michigan
Posts: 42,325
omg. all this hullaballou over some sexual feelings? Too bad I didn't find PC earlier, or that I wasn't less circumspect in starting threads. The point is, I think, many of us have had sexual feelings towards our T. We didn't die from them. Yes, your T, after 3 years, and all this hand-holding, was entirely within her rights to point it out to you. I think you're trying to distract yourself from your embarrassment about your feelings about it with all this rigamarole about everything else. You're trying to control it, or her, rather than accept it. What would happen if you just said yes, you were embarrassed, you had sexual feelings? Instead of arguing about WHEN you had sexual feelings? I for one don't believe she got it wrong. Anybody can feel the energy, the tension in the air.
Thanks for this!
scorpiosis37, trdleblue
  #92  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 10:33 AM
Anonymous32910
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Quote:
Originally Posted by rainbow8 View Post
Thanks, Lola. I do see what you're saying but to me, it looked like my "critics" were at it again, and I was being attacked with no one supporting me. I use the "thanks" button too, but it often seems to me, especially in my threads, that there are 2 sides: my critics and my supporters. The critics thank each other and that feels like a knife in my heart. I'm not saying it's accurate, and maybe it IS selfish, but those are my feelings. It seems like a war to me and I don't have the strength for it. I am going to have to figure out how to think differently next time so I don't get triggered, and to accept the criticism. Accepting criticism is hard.

Well, apparently I'm one of your "critics" and I was "at it again" as I was one of two people who had responded to your initial post before you went off on the whole forum. I was not attacking you at all. I WAS trying to help you see a different perspective frrom how you were "reading" things. If that is, in your eyes, "criticism" and you have either "critics or supporters" (rather black and white thinking don't you think?), then apparently nothing I said was in any way supportive. That's a shame as I was truly trying to be supportive.

I hope you will slow yourself down and truly try to absorb what your "critics" have to say rather than rejecting us outright as the enemy because I dare say you even see your DBT T and your own T as your "critics" if they so much as offer an idea that you feel shows you in any negative light. As I said in my initial post to you (ironically enough), this seems to go back to that general problem you have with shame and how you perceive any "mistake" or "correction" as a shaming event. Sounds like something to work on.
Thanks for this!
rainbow8
  #93  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 10:38 AM
rainbow8's Avatar
rainbow8 rainbow8 is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: US
Posts: 13,284
Quote:
Originally Posted by hankster View Post
omg. all this hullaballou over some sexual feelings? Too bad I didn't find PC earlier, or that I wasn't less circumspect in starting threads. The point is, I think, many of us have had sexual feelings towards our T. We didn't die from them. Yes, your T, after 3 years, and all this hand-holding, was entirely within her rights to point it out to you. I think you're trying to distract yourself from your embarrassment about your feelings about it with all this rigamarole about everything else. You're trying to control it, or her, rather than accept it. What would happen if you just said yes, you were embarrassed, you had sexual feelings? Instead of arguing about WHEN you had sexual feelings? I for one don't believe she got it wrong. Anybody can feel the energy, the tension in the air.
You're probably correct. It doesn't matter "when" since it's there other times. I'm ashamed of those feelings. I had them for my first T too, just as strong as for this one. But she told me they were sensual, not sexual. I don't know if she was right or wrong.
  #94  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 10:40 AM
Anonymous32516
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
For an adult to have " erotic " feelings /transference towards their T when STUCK in a mother/infant symbioses in normal. Adult entering therapy may interpretate those feelings as erotic. Heck I am straight and have had this experience with a female T. Only I am glad I wasnīt STUCK for years. Itīs complety normal and not worth 80 pages or a deeper analysis. ( Other than in T)
Thanks for this!
rainbow8
  #95  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 10:43 AM
rainbow8's Avatar
rainbow8 rainbow8 is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: US
Posts: 13,284
Quote:
Originally Posted by farmergirl View Post
Well, apparently I'm one of your "critics" and I was "at it again" as I was one of two people who had responded to your initial post before you went off on the whole forum. I was not attacking you at all. I WAS trying to help you see a different perspective frrom how you were "reading" things. If that is, in your eyes, "criticism" and you have either "critics or supporters" (rather black and white thinking don't you think?), then apparently nothing I said was in any way supportive. That's a shame as I was truly trying to be supportive.

I hope you will slow yourself down and truly try to absorb what your "critics" have to say rather than rejecting us outright as the enemy because I dare say you even see your DBT T and your own T as your "critics" if they so much as offer an idea that you feel shows you in any negative light. As I said in my initial post to you (ironically enough), this seems to go back to that general problem you have with shame and how you perceive any "mistake" or "correction" as a shaming event. Sounds like something to work on.
No, you are not one of my critics, Chris. You've been fair and helpful. You're healthy enough so that my threads don't trigger you. Others attack me because they are triggered and I'm beginning to understand that rationally but emotionally I'm still trying to not react. You ARE being supportive to me. Yes, I take criticism badly, and being ignored as criticism, and yes, it's something to work on. Thank you very much for your honesty and constructive, yet compassionate posts to me.

Last edited by rainbow8; Nov 18, 2012 at 10:52 AM. Reason: typo
  #96  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 10:49 AM
Sannah's Avatar
Sannah Sannah is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Jul 2008
Posts: 19,179
I couldn't read all the replies because I am late to the thread and there are too many. I think that you are getting to the heart of your issues in session Rainbow. You are doing good work with your T. Dealing with the core issues is painful, distressful and embarrassing, all normal feelings and reactions. Keep working in session!

It seems that this thread is your attempt to deal with your discomfort from working through your issues? And then some people get triggered by your attempts to deal with your discomfort?

The way that I see it is that you are dealing with your core issues in session and then you are using your coping mechanisms to deal with the fall out from session when you are out of session. I think that as long as you are dealing with your real issues in session that we should cut you some slack when you are trying to cope outside of session.
__________________
Don't let your problems or the world make you feel small. Stretch your arms out over your head. Take a deep breathe. Tell yourself that you are big. You are big, not small. You always have space, you are not trapped........

I'm an ISFJ
Thanks for this!
ECHOES, rainbow8, rainbow_rose, stopdog
  #97  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 11:02 AM
2or3things's Avatar
2or3things 2or3things is offline
Member
 
Member Since: May 2011
Location: turns out it really doesn't matter
Posts: 328
Can I just point out that disagreeing with a poster doesn't mean that one is necessarily triggered? I think most of us really don't "know" each other in any real sense of the word. (I do understand that some may have off-PC relationships, of course, so there might be exceptions.) While I think of myself as a caring person, in general, I'm not sure I'd say that people's statements or disagreements (with me or others) on PC "trigger" me. I don't have enough of an emotional investment in anyone I don't really know to be triggered by their stuff. There are a few people here that I'm really pulling for--Sarah Michelle, Nightsky, and Granite come to mind, for instance--and I wish everyone well. Still, people's "stuff" belongs with them, not me.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that suggesting one's critics are critics because they're triggered is a convenient way to be able to ignore the wisdom of what they say if it rubs one the wrong way.

Just a thought.
Thanks for this!
autotelica, feralkittymom, PreacherHeckler, scorpiosis37, venusss, WikidPissah
  #98  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 11:03 AM
Anne2.0 Anne2.0 is offline
Grand Magnate
 
Member Since: Aug 2012
Location: Anonymous
Posts: 3,132
Quote:
Originally Posted by rainbow8 View Post
Anne, please look back at page one. I had 2 responses, from hankster and farmergirl. Then I saw the "thanks" to fg (there weren't as many as now) with no hugs or reponses to me, and I got triggered. I should have been more patient but I was afraid my thread would disappear and I was feeling bad about the issue in my session. I still am, but am living with those feelings until Tuesday.
Rainbow, I am not an idiot and I do not need to go back to anywhere. I read and comprehend just fine. I saw the responses. What I did not see is all the interpretive meaning you put into this situation, which is that two responses in about an hour means you are being ignored. It is your interpretation of the board's responses to you that is distorted and unhealthy, not what you actually get back here. What you get back here, realistically, is quantitatively and qualitative far more than most people get in response to their posts. You may not be getting the fluffy stuff of support that you want, but people, even your "critics", GIVE a lot to you, in terms of their time and their willingness to be straight with you.

It seems to me that you are willing to USE other people, and manipulate other people's feelings, in order to satisfy your needs for attention. That is not something I have seen you change, or work towards changing, and although I don't find it triggering per se, it ends up with me feeling kind of icky and squeamish for having participated in something that I think has ultimately met your unhealthy needs more than perhaps your healthy needs.

The fact that you see that the problem with my "criticism" of you is that I failed to read the posts, rather than your f*ed up interpretation of it, points towards a lack of change in this domain. I do see you as having made progress towards dealing with your CSA issues by just writing this post, but there is a heck of a lot more there for you to work with than you allow yourself to do. Instead I think you manufacture this kind of drama that serves as a distraction, like spies who blow up one building so they can escape in the other direction. I think you keep running away from the issues you need to deal with, maybe unconsciously, maybe consciously, but I'm personally kind of at the end of my tolerance for it.

But as long as you engage in this unhealthy helpseeking behavior, criticizing this board for ignoring you, being mean to you, having "camps" where one side is against you, and threatening to leave, you can guarantee that people will continue to view your thread (3,000+ views right now) and respond to your posts (more than 80 responses now). I can see how you wouldn't want to give this up and focus on the real things you could hash out here-- it would mean the loss of something (attention) that is just too precious to you.
Thanks for this!
2or3things, pbutton, rainbow8, scorpiosis37, trdleblue, WikidPissah
  #99  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 11:06 AM
Sannah's Avatar
Sannah Sannah is offline
Legendary
 
Member Since: Jul 2008
Posts: 19,179
I said "some" people are triggered.
__________________
Don't let your problems or the world make you feel small. Stretch your arms out over your head. Take a deep breathe. Tell yourself that you are big. You are big, not small. You always have space, you are not trapped........

I'm an ISFJ
  #100  
Old Nov 18, 2012, 11:07 AM
Anonymous32910
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sannah View Post
I said "some" people are triggered.
Sannah, Anne was referring to Rainbow's own words, not yours.
Thanks for this!
Anne2.0, Sannah
Closed Thread
Views: 10690

attentionThis is an old thread. You probably should not post your reply to it, as the original poster is unlikely to see it.




All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:38 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® — Copyright © 2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.




 

My Support Forums

My Support Forums is the online community that was originally begun as the Psych Central Forums in 2001. It now runs as an independent self-help support group community for mental health, personality, and psychological issues and is overseen by a group of dedicated, caring volunteers from around the world.

 

Helplines and Lifelines

The material on this site is for informational purposes only, and is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment provided by a qualified health care provider.

Always consult your doctor or mental health professional before trying anything you read here.