Home Menu

Menu


Reply
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 03:28 PM
CantExplain's Avatar
CantExplain CantExplain is offline
Big Poppa
 
Member Since: Oct 2011
Location: New Zealand
Posts: 19,616
Why do therapists think that withholding love is therapeutic?
__________________
Mr Ambassador, alias Ancient Plax, alias Captain Therapy, alias Big Poppa, alias Secret Spy, etc.

Add that to your tattoo, Baby!

advertisement
  #2  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 03:29 PM
Anonymous100110
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
I've never had a therapist withhold love. What are you defining as withholding love exactly?
  #3  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 03:33 PM
stopdog stopdog is offline
underdog is here
 
Member Since: Sep 2011
Location: blank
Posts: 35,154
I don't know why a therapist would think of themselves, love and me in the same sentence ever.
__________________
Please NO @

Selfishness is not living as one wishes to live, it is asking others to live as one wishes to live.
Oscar Wilde
Well Behaved Women Seldom Make History - Laurel Thatcher Ulrich
Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.
  #4  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 03:35 PM
nicoleflynn nicoleflynn is offline
Grand Magnate
 
Member Since: Jan 2012
Location: rochester, michigan
Posts: 3,111
Therapists need to love their clients, or it won't work.......
  #5  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 03:37 PM
stopdog stopdog is offline
underdog is here
 
Member Since: Sep 2011
Location: blank
Posts: 35,154
Quote:
Originally Posted by nicoleflynn View Post
Therapists need to love their clients, or it won't work.......
I don't think this is universally true. I doubt they even need to like a client. It may be so for some, but I hope I have found those for whom it is not. I don't want them thinking they love me in any sense of the word. God knows I don't love them.
__________________
Please NO @

Selfishness is not living as one wishes to live, it is asking others to live as one wishes to live.
Oscar Wilde
Well Behaved Women Seldom Make History - Laurel Thatcher Ulrich
Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.
  #6  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 03:43 PM
brillskep brillskep is offline
Poohbah
 
Member Since: Dec 2013
Location: Europe
Posts: 1,256
That sounds like a generalization ...I don't know what to answer you. I don't think withholding love is therapeutic, nor do therapists I know seem to think that. Even the worst therapist I've ever met doesn't seem to think that. But I think it depends on perspective. I mean, I think there is a big difference between withholding love and keeping healthy boundaries so the therapist doesn't burn out. I believe there needs to be a measure of love in therapy, but it's unethical for a therapist to extend and act out all their love for clients ... there are bound to be clients a therapist will like more than others, clients a therapist would like to help more than others. It's just a human thing. But it's unethical to make differences like that, offer special treatment to some clients and not make the same efforts for others just because of subjective standards and personal feelings. So these boundaries are there to protect both therapist and client.
  #7  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 03:46 PM
Anonymous100110
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Quote:
Originally Posted by nicoleflynn View Post
Therapists need to love their clients, or it won't work.......
Not necessarily. Caring genuinely about a client's welfare is probably enough on their end. I suspect it is the clients that get hung up on the "love" aspect, not the therapists for the most part. Love may be a bit of a strong term to be used as an absolute "must" or "it won't work". I do think people in caring professions actually need to care, but that may come short of actual "love" feelings (and no, I'm not talking about romantic feelings).
Thanks for this!
Favorite Jeans, feralkittymom, PreacherHeckler
  #8  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 04:19 PM
Perna's Avatar
Perna Perna is offline
Pandita-in-training
 
Member Since: Sep 2006
Location: Maryland
Posts: 27,289
Both day and night are therapeutic. You cannot have one without the other. Or, as one of my favorite quotes puts it, an Arabian proverb: All sun makes a desert.
__________________
"Never give a sword to a man who can't dance." ~Confucius
Thanks for this!
Gavinandnikki
  #9  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 04:21 PM
sweepy62's Avatar
sweepy62 sweepy62 is offline
Grand Magnate
 
Member Since: Sep 2011
Location: usa
Posts: 3,642
I never knew love was required , I know they care about the clients best interest , that's enough for me. I don't think I would believe a t if they tell me they loved me.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
__________________
Bipolar 1
Gad
Ptsd

BPD

ZOLOFT 100
TOPAMAX 400
ABILIFY 10
SYNTHROID 137

Thanks for this!
Bill3
  #10  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 05:38 PM
Anonymous32735
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Quote:
Originally Posted by CantExplain View Post
Why do therapists think that withholding love is therapeutic?
Maybe i'm in the minority here, but it wouldn't be the first time...I don't think it's withholding love; it's withholding enmeshment, which to many of us, might seem like withholding love. An easy way to explain this is--if your therapist were to give you what you needed, she'd be sort of 'people pleasing', rather than being a separate person from you.

Attachment is one-sided, child/immature love. Mature love involves being separate from another (but connected/bonded). So to answer your question: when a therapist withholds enmeshment, it helps us construct psychological boundaries, which provides us with the framework needed for mature love.

A therapist giving us or becoming what we want/need is not love. A therapist's unconditional acceptance, compassion, support, validation, etc., is love.
Thanks for this!
Asiablue, Bells129, Bill3, feralkittymom, JustShakey, kororain, pbutton, scorpiosis37, tinyrabbit, unaluna
  #11  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 06:30 PM
msxyz's Avatar
msxyz msxyz is offline
Member
 
Member Since: Nov 2010
Location: PNW
Posts: 492
Quote:
Originally Posted by skies View Post
Maybe i'm in the minority here, but it wouldn't be the first time...I don't think it's withholding love; it's withholding enmeshment, which to many of us, might seem like withholding love. An easy way to explain this is--if your therapist were to give you what you needed, she'd be sort of 'people pleasing', rather than being a separate person from you.

Attachment is one-sided, child/immature love. Mature love involves being separate from another (but connected/bonded). So to answer your question: when a therapist withholds enmeshment, it helps us construct psychological boundaries, which provides us with the framework needed for mature love.

A therapist giving us or becoming what we want/need is not love. A therapist's unconditional acceptance, compassion, support, validation, etc., is love.
What do you mean with "attachment is one sided, child/immature love"?
  #12  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 06:43 PM
Anonymous32735
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Quote:
Originally Posted by Akama View Post
What do you mean with "attachment is one sided, child/immature love"?
That is meant to distinguish attachment vs. adult relationship. There is a concept of adult attachment, but generally, I think attachment is often referred to in the context of how it's described here:

Quote:
Clarification of definitions

Attachment is a frequently used term in the field of relationships. As we learn more about this subject, controversies continue to emerge and some common misconceptions remain. Health professionals can benefit from knowing more about the historical evolution of the concept of attachment. They can also benefit from a survey of terminology used in the vast literature related to the topic and a review of current research on different aspects of this familiar but complex subject.

Parents may approach physicians and other health professionals with questions and concerns related to “attachment.” Despite an abundance of information on attachment, there is often confusion surrounding the term. What is the meaning of attachment and what do we really know about attachment and its relationship to mental health?

An attachment relationship is enduring and biologically based. Important points include the following:

• Attachment is a reciprocal but unequal relationship.

• The infant seeks proximity to the maternal figure, who is supposed to be wiser and more capable, providing protection and “felt security.”[16]

• The relationship is unequal in that the mother should not be expected to seek protection or comforting from her infant; unfortunately, the latter is seen in disturbed attachment scenarios.

The terms attachment and bonding are sometimes used interchangeably to indicate either the parent’s emotional tie to the infant or the infant’s to the parent. Their respective meanings are, however, different. An infant is attached to his or her parent, whereas parents are described as bonded to their infants.
http://www.bcmj.org/article/attachme...l-perspectives

So, it's much like the therapist-client relationship rather than a mutual, adult relationship. We are a diverse group, so people here might use the term in different ways that I would.

I hope this helps clarify things.
Thanks for this!
feralkittymom, Intenseblue, unaluna
  #13  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 06:55 PM
shabur's Avatar
shabur shabur is offline
Member
 
Member Since: Feb 2014
Location: Illinois
Posts: 437
I want my Ts to care about me and I know they do. I don't expect them to love me anymore than they love society in general.
  #14  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 07:11 PM
elliemay's Avatar
elliemay elliemay is offline
Grand Magnate
 
Member Since: Jun 2007
Posts: 3,555
I think love is something we cultivate in our lives, not in our therapy. I didn't go to therapist to buy love. I went there to get some help.

That help has opened the door to love in my "real" life.

It's complicated, but I am so grateful that my therapist had enough training and professionalism to NOT love me back. It made me look at myself. Sometimes I really didn't like what I saw.

But worth it. So very worth it.
__________________
.........................
Hugs from:
brillskep
Thanks for this!
Bill3, BonnieJean, feralkittymom, PreacherHeckler, Rive.
  #15  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 07:31 PM
unaluna's Avatar
unaluna unaluna is offline
Elder Harridan x-hankster
 
Member Since: Jun 2011
Location: Milan/Michigan
Posts: 42,261
Growing up in catholic school, they threw the word love around a LOT. God loves you, this sacrifice was made out of love, all his children are loved, etc etc etc. It was pretty constant. You joined the Peace Corps out of love for your fellow man, not for how it looked on your college application or your resume. As JFK said, Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country. I think for me, its that kind of love, rather than romantic or committed. More like beer commercial i love you guys. Beatles all you need is love love.
Hugs from:
Wysteria
  #16  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 07:48 PM
healingme4me's Avatar
healingme4me healingme4me is offline
Perpetually Pondering
Community Liaison
 
Member Since: Apr 2013
Location: New England
Posts: 46,298
Quote:
Originally Posted by CantExplain View Post
Why do therapists think that withholding love is therapeutic?
Leaving love out of the equation, unless my T specifically states something, is it up to me to know[what they think], without asking?

Did your T specifically state, they are withholding love from you, as part of your therapy?

Sent from my LGMS323 using Tapatalk
Thanks for this!
brillskep, Wysteria
  #17  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 07:51 PM
Gavinandnikki's Avatar
Gavinandnikki Gavinandnikki is offline
Grand Member
 
Member Since: Apr 2013
Location: Texas
Posts: 872
Because some of them are sadists.
__________________
Pam
Hugs from:
Anonymous32735
  #18  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 07:56 PM
Anonymous43207
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
My t doesn't withhold love. But she sorta defines that "love" at the same time by saying something like this "There are different kinds of love, and there is a kind of love in therapy, don't you think?" This was when I was still saying "I love you." Strangely, I don't feel the need to do that anymore. Not strange really I guess, it happened at the same time I forgave my mom.....
Hugs from:
Wysteria
Thanks for this!
feralkittymom
  #19  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 08:22 PM
IndestructibleGirl's Avatar
IndestructibleGirl IndestructibleGirl is offline
Grand Poohbah
 
Member Since: Sep 2013
Posts: 1,654
Quote:
Originally Posted by 1914sierra View Post
Not necessarily. Caring genuinely about a client's welfare is probably enough on their end. I suspect it is the clients that get hung up on the "love" aspect, not the therapists for the most part. Love may be a bit of a strong term to be used as an absolute "must" or "it won't work". I do think people in caring professions actually need to care, but that may come short of actual "love" feelings (and no, I'm not talking about romantic feelings).
You could argue that this is about semantics. Authentic caring feelings come under an umbrella of 'love' as far as I am concerned.

Philanthropic love = genuinely caring for the client. Just phrased differently. Love is a broad church and we all do it differently, but this is my take on it.
__________________
Been trying hard not to get into trouble, but I
I got a war in my mind
~ Lana Del Rey

How many cares one loses when one decides not to be something but to be someone
~ Coco Chanel

One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman
~ Simone de Beauvoir
Thanks for this!
Wysteria
  #20  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 08:33 PM
msxyz's Avatar
msxyz msxyz is offline
Member
 
Member Since: Nov 2010
Location: PNW
Posts: 492
Quote:
Originally Posted by skies View Post
That is meant to distinguish attachment vs. adult relationship. There is a concept of adult attachment, but generally, I think attachment is often referred to in the context of how it's described here:


http://www.bcmj.org/article/attachme...l-perspectives

So, it's much like the therapist-client relationship rather than a mutual, adult relationship. We are a diverse group, so people here might use the term in different ways that I would.

I hope this helps clarify things.
I haven't quite seen it explained like this before.
  #21  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 08:57 PM
Anonymous32735
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Quote:
Originally Posted by Akama View Post
I haven't quite seen it explained like this before.
Yes, but I think this is the more objective and clinically correct meaning in context of psychotherapy. Attachment and transference are applied very broadly here; they are also mixed up or transposed. It's normal to do this, but it does change the meaning in many ways. So it's not just a issue of semantics.
  #22  
Old Jun 06, 2014, 11:48 PM
Wysteria's Avatar
Wysteria Wysteria is offline
Grand Member
 
Member Since: May 2011
Location: nowhere
Posts: 807
I don't think that therapists have to Love their clients....after a long period of time, they often care/love about them deeply.

I recently read a book about young T's in training. this one dude was having trouble even "liking" his client...and therapy was not progressing. In his session/review with supervisor...the supervisor gently taught him how to empathize with the patient and sort of see the world through her eyes...Then, and only then could therapy really progress.

Thus "withholding" love may be an assumption on your part, may be helpful in setting boundaries, goes against the T's own personal boundaries and capabilities, or is too "new" to learn to control and tamper emotions down to truly focus on you...

Hope maybe that just gives you a bit different way of seeing things..

wb
__________________


Your vision will become clear only when you can look into your heart.
Who looks outside, Dreams...
Who looks inside, Awakens...
- Carl Jung
Thanks for this!
Bells129
  #23  
Old Jun 07, 2014, 12:09 AM
kororain's Avatar
kororain kororain is offline
Member
 
Member Since: May 2014
Location: USA
Posts: 409
Quote:
Originally Posted by skies View Post
Maybe i'm in the minority here, but it wouldn't be the first time...I don't think it's withholding love; it's withholding enmeshment, which to many of us, might seem like withholding love. An easy way to explain this is--if your therapist were to give you what you needed, she'd be sort of 'people pleasing', rather than being a separate person from you.

Attachment is one-sided, child/immature love. Mature love involves being separate from another (but connected/bonded). So to answer your question: when a therapist withholds enmeshment, it helps us construct psychological boundaries, which provides us with the framework needed for mature love.

A therapist giving us or becoming what we want/need is not love. A therapist's unconditional acceptance, compassion, support, validation, etc., is love.
Well that just summed up what's wrong with me. Mind. Blown.
Hugs from:
Anonymous32735
  #24  
Old Jun 07, 2014, 04:08 AM
feralkittymom's Avatar
feralkittymom feralkittymom is offline
Grand Magnate
 
Member Since: Aug 2012
Location: yada
Posts: 4,415
As adults, we don't get to define for, nor demand from, others the forms taken of emotions extended to us. The "path of yes" is, in part, a recognition of this reality.
Thanks for this!
pbutton
  #25  
Old Jun 07, 2014, 06:54 AM
Anonymous32735
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Quote:
Originally Posted by feralkittymom View Post
The "path of yes" is, in part, a recognition of this reality.
What exactly is the path of yes?
Thanks for this!
Wysteria
Reply
Views: 2909

attentionThis is an old thread. You probably should not post your reply to it, as the original poster is unlikely to see it.




All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:24 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® — Copyright © 2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.




 

My Support Forums

My Support Forums is the online community that was originally begun as the Psych Central Forums in 2001. It now runs as an independent self-help support group community for mental health, personality, and psychological issues and is overseen by a group of dedicated, caring volunteers from around the world.

 

Helplines and Lifelines

The material on this site is for informational purposes only, and is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment provided by a qualified health care provider.

Always consult your doctor or mental health professional before trying anything you read here.